Iyer Sravisht, Bovonratwet Patawut, Samartzis Dino, Schoenfeld Andrew J, An Howard S, Awwad Waleed, Blumenthal Scott L, Cheung Jason P Y, Derman Peter B, El-Sharkawi Mohammad, Freedman Brett A, Hartl Roger, Kang James D, Kim Han Jo, Louie Philip K, Ludwig Steven C, Neva Marko H, Pham Martin H, Phillips Frank M, Qureshi Sheeraz A, Radcliff Kris E, Riew K Daniel, Sandhu Harvinder S, Sciubba Daniel M, Sethi Rajiv K, Valacco Marcelo, Zaidi Hasan A, Zygourakis Corinna C, Makhni Melvin C
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Hospital for Special Surgery, 535 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2022 Apr 15;47(8):583-590. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0000000000004339. Epub 2022 Feb 4.
Delphi expert panel consensus.
To obtain expert consensus on best practices for appropriate telemedicine utilization in spine surgery.
Several studies have shown high patient satisfaction associated with telemedicine during the COVID-19 peak pandemic period as well as after easing of restrictions. As this technology will most likely continue to be employed, there is a need to define appropriate utilization.
An expert panel consisting of 27 spine surgeons from various countries was assembled in February 2021. A two-round consensus-based Delphi method was used to generate consensus statements on various aspects of telemedicine (separated as video visits or audio visits) including themes, such as patient location and impact of patient diagnosis, on assessment of new patients. Topics with ≥75% agreement were categorized as having achieved a consensus.
The expert panel reviewed a total of 59 statements. Of these, 32 achieved consensus. The panel had consensus that video visits could be utilized regardless of patient location and that video visits are appropriate for evaluating as well as indicating for surgery multiple common spine pathologies, such as lumbar stenosis, lumbar radiculopathy, and cervical radiculopathy. Finally, the panel had consensus that video visits could be appropriate for a variety of visit types including early, midterm, longer term postoperative follow-up, follow-up for imaging review, and follow-up after an intervention (i.e., physical therapy, injection).
Although telemedicine was initially introduced out of necessity, this technology most likely will remain due to evidence of high patient satisfaction and significant cost savings. This study was able to provide a framework for appropriate telemedicine utilization in spine surgery from a panel of experts. However, several questions remain for future research, such as whether or not an in-person consultation is necessary prior to surgery and which physical exam maneuvers are appropriate for telemedicine.Level of Evidence: 4.
德尔菲专家小组共识。
就脊柱外科中适当使用远程医疗的最佳实践达成专家共识。
多项研究表明,在新冠疫情高峰期以及限制放宽后,患者对远程医疗的满意度较高。由于这项技术很可能会继续被采用,因此有必要明确其适当的使用方法。
2021年2月组建了一个由来自不同国家的27名脊柱外科医生组成的专家小组。采用两轮基于共识的德尔菲方法,就远程医疗的各个方面(分为视频问诊或音频问诊)生成共识声明,包括患者位置和患者诊断对新患者评估的影响等主题。达成≥75%共识的主题被归类为达成了共识。
专家小组共审查了59项声明。其中32项达成了共识。专家小组达成的共识是,无论患者身在何处都可以使用视频问诊,并且视频问诊适用于评估以及诊断多种常见的脊柱疾病,如腰椎管狭窄症、腰椎神经根病和颈椎病,以决定是否需要手术。最后,专家小组达成的共识是,视频问诊适用于多种问诊类型,包括早期、中期、长期术后随访、影像复查随访以及干预(如物理治疗、注射)后的随访。
虽然远程医疗最初是出于必要而引入的,但由于有证据表明患者满意度高且能显著节省成本,这项技术很可能会继续存在。本研究能够为专家小组在脊柱外科中适当使用远程医疗提供一个框架。然而,未来的研究仍有几个问题有待解决,例如手术前是否需要进行面对面咨询,以及哪些体格检查操作适用于远程医疗。证据级别:4级。