Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (KU Leuven), Parkstraat 45, 3000, Leuven, Belgium.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2023 Jan;30(4):8672-8681. doi: 10.1007/s11356-022-18836-5. Epub 2022 Feb 9.
Globally, E-waste is experiencing an unprecedented growth in the recent years. This growth will be fueled further by the COVID-19 pandemic owing to the new work culture where people are becoming more dependent on their electronic products than ever before. However, governance of E-waste, particularly in the Global South, has been a complex phenomenon. Considering this, the current study attempted to assess the design, adoption, and implementation of E-waste policies in India-a major electronics manufacturing hub with a massive consumer electronics market. Taking hints from theoretical concepts such as policy transfer, policy convergence, and policy effectiveness, the study addressed the primary research question: why India adopts E-waste policy approaches that seem inadequate and ineffective in its local contexts and attempts to identify alternative approaches. Through expert interviews and policy document analysis, it was observed that E-waste policy approaches in India are largely influenced by the European Union's Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Directive. All the experts interviewed recognized absence of the informal sector in India's policy efforts of both 2011 and 2016 as a significant lacuna in the country's E-waste policy responses. In this paper, the author argues that there should be policy change towards a healthy collaboration between the informal and formal sector where best-of-the-two-worlds could be wisely used for sustainable E-waste governance in India.
在全球范围内,电子废物近年来呈前所未有的增长态势。由于新的工作文化,人们比以往任何时候都更加依赖电子产品,这种增长将因 COVID-19 大流行而进一步加剧。然而,电子废物的治理,特别是在全球南方,一直是一个复杂的现象。有鉴于此,本研究试图评估印度电子废物政策的设计、采用和实施情况——印度是一个主要的电子产品制造中心,拥有庞大的消费电子产品市场。本研究借鉴政策转移、政策趋同和政策有效性等理论概念,提出了一个主要研究问题:为什么印度采用的电子废物政策方法在其本地环境中似乎不够充分和无效,并试图确定替代方法。通过专家访谈和政策文件分析,观察到印度的电子废物政策方法在很大程度上受到欧盟《废弃电气和电子设备指令》(WEEE)的影响。所有接受采访的专家都认识到,印度在 2011 年和 2016 年的政策努力中都没有考虑到印度的非正规部门,这是印度电子废物政策应对措施中的一个重大空白。本文作者认为,应该朝着非正式部门和正式部门之间的健康合作方向进行政策变革,明智地利用两个世界中最好的方法,为印度的可持续电子废物治理做出贡献。