Kaur Chamandeep, Singh Preeti, Sahni Sukhtej
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Panjab University Chandigarh, Chandigarh, India.
Department of Psychiatry, Cheema Medical Complex, Mohali, India.
Basic Clin Neurosci. 2021 Jul-Aug;12(4):465-476. doi: 10.32598/bcn.2021.1388.2. Epub 2021 Jul 1.
Several computer-aided diagnosis systems for depression are suggested for use by clinicians to authorize the diagnosis. EEG may be used as an objective analysis tool for identifying depression in the initial stage to avoid it from reaching a severe and permanent state. However, artifact contamination reduces the accuracy in EEG signal processing systems.
This work proposes a novel denoising method based on Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) (with Detrended Fluctuation Analysis (DFA) and wavelet packet transform. Initially, real EEG recordings corresponding to depression patients are decomposed into various mode functions by applying EMD. Then, DFA is used as the mode selection criteria. Further Wavelet Packets Decomposition (WPD)-based evaluation is applied to extract the cleaner signal.
Simulations were conducted on real EEG databases for depression to demonstrate the effects of the proposed techniques. To conclude the efficacy of the proposed technique, SNR and MAE were identified. The obtained results indicated improved signal-to-noise ratio and lower values of MAE for the combined EMD-DFA-WPD technique. Additionally, Random Forest and SVM (Support Vector Machine)-based classification revealed the improved accuracy of 98.51% and 98.10% for the proposed denoising technique. Whereas the accuracy of the EMD- DFA is 98.01% and 95.81% and EMD combined with DWT technique equaled98.0% and 97.21% for the EMD- DFA technique for RF and SVM, respectively, compared to the proposed method. Furthermore, the classification performance for both classifiers was compared with and without denoising to highlight the effects of the proposed technique.
Proposed denoising system results in better classification of depressed and healthy individuals resulting in a better diagnosing system. These results can be further analyzed using other approaches as a solution to the mode mixing problem of the EMD approach.
临床医生建议使用几种用于抑郁症的计算机辅助诊断系统来进行诊断授权。脑电图(EEG)可作为在初始阶段识别抑郁症的客观分析工具,以避免其发展到严重且永久性的状态。然而,伪迹污染会降低EEG信号处理系统的准确性。
这项工作提出了一种基于经验模态分解(EMD)(结合去趋势波动分析(DFA)和小波包变换)的新型去噪方法。首先,通过应用EMD将与抑郁症患者对应的真实EEG记录分解为各种模态函数。然后,将DFA用作模态选择标准。进一步应用基于小波包分解(WPD)的评估来提取更纯净的信号。
在真实的抑郁症EEG数据库上进行了模拟,以证明所提出技术的效果。为了总结所提出技术的有效性,确定了信噪比(SNR)和平均绝对误差(MAE)。获得的结果表明,对于EMD-DFA-WPD组合技术,信噪比得到了提高,MAE值更低。此外,基于随机森林(Random Forest)和支持向量机(SVM)的分类显示,所提出的去噪技术的准确率分别提高到了98.51%和98.10%。而对于EMD-DFA技术,与所提出的方法相比,RF和SVM的准确率分别为98.01%和95.81%,EMD与离散小波变换(DWT)技术相结合的方法在RF和SVM中的准确率分别为98.0%和97.21%。此外,比较了有无去噪情况下两个分类器的分类性能,以突出所提出技术的效果。
所提出的去噪系统能够更好地对抑郁症患者和健康个体进行分类,从而形成一个更好的诊断系统。这些结果可以使用其他方法进一步分析,以解决EMD方法的模态混叠问题。