School of Health and Human Performance, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
School of Health and Human Performance, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
J Biomech. 2022 Mar;134:111000. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2022.111000. Epub 2022 Feb 15.
The purpose of this research was to validate the use of a low-cost IMU system to measure upper-limb joint angles by comparing it to passive optical motion capture measures. Fifteen participants (five females; 25.9 ± 4.7 years) completed one trial of four simple range of motion (ROM) movements (elbow flexion/extension, shoulder abduction/adduction, shoulder flexion/extension, and shoulder internal/external rotation), and three complex functional daily tasks [hand to: back pocket (HBP), contralateral shoulder (HCS), head (HTH)]. Movements were measured, simultaneously, using fourteen OptiTrack cameras and five Notch® IMUs. The mean joint angle difference between devices ranged from 0.10° ± 3.11° for the HBP shoulder internal/external movement to 44.95° ± 3.50° for the simple ROM shoulder internal/external rotation movement. Nine of sixteen movement and plane comparisons showed significant differences between the device-specific movement cycle waveforms. Eleven of the comparisons showed either fixed and/or proportional biases (fixed only: 9; proportional only: 1; both fixed and proportional: 1). Due to multiple movements having large amplitude errors, low waveform similarities, and/or statistically significant mean differences between the Notch® IMUs and the gold-standard motion capture devices, we cannot recommend that Notch® IMUs are valid devices for measuring upper-limb joint angles during simple ROM and complex functional daily tasks.
本研究旨在通过与被动光学运动捕捉测量相比,验证低成本惯性测量单元 (IMU) 系统在测量上肢关节角度方面的应用。十五名参与者(女性 5 名;25.9 ± 4.7 岁)完成了四项简单运动范围 (ROM) 运动(肘部屈伸、肩部外展/内收、肩部屈伸和肩部内旋/外旋)和三项复杂日常功能任务[手到:后口袋 (HBP)、对侧肩部 (HCS)、头部 (HTH)]的一次试验。使用十四台 OptiTrack 摄像机和五台 Notch®IMU 同时测量运动。设备之间的平均关节角度差异范围从 HBP 肩部内旋/外旋运动的 0.10°±3.11°到简单 ROM 肩部内旋/外旋运动的 44.95°±3.50°。在十六个运动和平面比较中有九个显示设备特定运动周期波形之间存在显著差异。十一次比较显示存在固定和/或比例偏差(仅固定:9;仅比例:1;固定和比例均有:1)。由于多个运动具有较大的幅度误差、低的波形相似性和/或 Notch®IMU 和黄金标准运动捕捉设备之间存在统计学上显著的平均差异,因此我们不能推荐 Notch®IMU 是测量简单 ROM 和复杂日常功能任务期间上肢关节角度的有效设备。