Division of Medical Oncology and Department of Medicine, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre and University of Toronto, 2075 Bayview Avenue, Toronto, ON, M4N 3M5, Canada.
Department of Surgery, London Health Sciences Centre and Western University, London, ON, Canada.
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2022 May;193(1):1-20. doi: 10.1007/s10549-022-06522-6. Epub 2022 Feb 28.
The neoadjuvant treatment of breast cancer (NABC) is a rapidly changing area that benefits from guidelines integrating evidence with expert consensus to help direct practice. This can optimize patient outcomes by ensuring the appropriate use of evolving neoadjuvant principles.
An expert panel formulated evidence-based practice recommendations spanning the entire neoadjuvant breast cancer treatment journey. These were sent for practice-based consensus across Canada using the modified Delphi methodology, through a secure online survey. Final recommendations were graded using the GRADE criteria for guidelines. The evidence was reviewed over the course of guideline development to ensure recommendations remained aligned with current relevant data.
Response rate to the online survey was almost 30%; representation was achieved from various medical specialties from both community and academic centres in various Canadian provinces. Two rounds of consensus were required to achieve 80% or higher consensus on 59 final statements. Five additional statements were added to reflect updated evidence but not sent for consensus.
Key highlights of this comprehensive Canadian guideline on NABC include the use of neoadjuvant therapy for early stage triple negative and HER2 positive breast cancer, with subsequent adjuvant treatments for patients with residual disease. The use of molecular signatures, other targeted adjuvant therapies, and optimal response-based local regional management remain actively evolving areas. Many statements had evolving or limited data but still achieved high consensus, demonstrating the utility of such a guideline in helping to unify practice while further evidence evolves in this important area of breast cancer management.
乳腺癌的新辅助治疗(NABC)是一个快速变化的领域,需要将证据与专家共识相结合的指南来指导实践,从而从中获益。这可以通过确保新辅助原则的合理应用来优化患者的治疗效果。
一个专家小组制定了涵盖整个新辅助乳腺癌治疗过程的循证实践建议。这些建议通过改良德尔菲法(modified Delphi methodology),通过安全的在线调查,在加拿大各地进行基于实践的共识。最终建议使用指南的 GRADE 标准进行分级。在指南制定过程中,对证据进行了审查,以确保建议与当前相关数据保持一致。
在线调查的回复率接近 30%;来自加拿大各个省份的社区和学术中心的各种医学专业都有代表参与。需要两轮共识才能就 59 项最终陈述达成 80%或更高的共识。另外增加了 5 项陈述,以反映更新的证据,但无需进行共识。
本项关于 NABC 的加拿大综合指南的主要重点包括将新辅助疗法用于早期三阴性和 HER2 阳性乳腺癌,随后对有残留疾病的患者进行辅助治疗。分子特征、其他靶向辅助治疗和最佳基于反应的局部区域管理的使用仍然是活跃的发展领域。许多陈述都有不断发展或有限的数据,但仍达成了高度共识,这表明在这个乳腺癌管理的重要领域,这样的指南在帮助统一实践的同时,随着进一步的证据发展,具有实用性。