α2-Adrenoceptors, subdivided into α2A, α2B, and α2C subtypes and expressed in heart, blood vessels, kidney, platelets and brain, are important for blood pressure, sedation, analgesia, and platelet aggregation. Brain α2C-adrenoceptor blockade has also been suggested to be beneficial for antipsychotic action. However, comparing α2-adrenoceptor subtype affinity is difficult due to significant species and methodology differences in published studies. Here, H-rauwolscine whole cell binding was used to determine the affinity and selectivity of 99 α-antagonists (including antidepressants and antipsychotics) in CHO cells expressing human α2A, α2B, or α2C-adrenoceptors, using an identical method to β and α1-adrenoceptor measurements, thus allowing direct human receptor comparisons. Yohimbine, RX821002, RS79948, and atipamezole are high affinity non-selective α2-antagonists. BRL44408 was the most α2A-selective antagonist, although its α1A-affinity (81 nM) is only 9-fold greater than its α2C-affinity. MK-912 is the highest-affinity, most α2C-selective antagonist (0.15 nM α2C-affinity) although its α2C-selectivity is only 13-fold greater than at α2A. There are no truely α2B-selective antagonists. A few α-ligands with significant β-affinity were detected, for example, naftopidil where its clinical α1A-affinity is only 3-fold greater than off-target β2-affinity. Antidepressants (except mirtazapine) and first-generation antipsychotics have higher α1A than α2-adrenoceptor affinity but poor β-affinity. Second-generation antipsychotics varied widely in their α2-adrenoceptor affinity. Risperidone (9 nM) and paliperidone (14 nM) have the highest α2C-adrenoceptor affinity however this is only 5-fold selective over α2A, and both have a higher affinity for α1A (2 nM and 4 nM, respectively). So, despite a century of yohimbine use, and decades of α2-subtype studies, there remains plenty of scope to develop α2-subtype selective antagonists.