Department of Construction Management, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China.
Hum Factors. 2024 Jan;66(1):221-233. doi: 10.1177/00187208211066666. Epub 2022 Feb 26.
The study aimed to reinvestigate psychological mechanisms of the influence of construction workers' experience on hazard recognition performance, with signal detection theory (SDT) and electroencephalogram (EEG) readings.
Existing evidence regarding the effect of experience on hazard recognition performance in the construction industry remains inconsistent. Behavior-wise, identification of dominant hazard recognition factors (sensitivity or response bias, or both) would help determine appropriate training strategies to improve hazard recognition. In terms of neuro-responses, induced gamma-band activity was expected to reflect the cognitive functions mediating the psychological effects of experience.
Seventy-seven construction workers participated in a predesigned hazard recognition task, in which participants judged whether a hazard was present from a series of construction scenario pictures. We computed and compared the sensitivity and response bias of SDT and time-frequency representations of recorded EEG signals of the two experience-level groups.
Novice workers had higher hazard recognition rates. Behavior-wise, novices were more sensitive than more experienced workers. Compared with experienced workers, novices showed stronger gamma-band difference power (hazardous minus safe) in the left frontal and right posterior parietal areas during the hazard recognition process.
Novices performed better at hazard recognition, indicating their sensitivity to the hazards without a clear difference in response bias. Based on the EEG data, novices' sensitivity may be attributed to more efficient working memory and attentional control.
There is a need for continuous refreshment of hazard recognition skills for experienced workers for safety interventions.
本研究旨在重新探讨建筑工人经验对危险识别性能影响的心理机制,采用信号检测理论(SDT)和脑电图(EEG)读数。
关于经验对建筑行业危险识别性能影响的现有证据仍然不一致。从行为角度来看,确定主导危险识别因素(敏感性或反应偏差,或两者兼而有之)将有助于确定适当的培训策略,以提高危险识别能力。就神经反应而言,诱导的伽马波段活动预计反映了介导经验心理效应的认知功能。
77 名建筑工人参与了预先设计的危险识别任务,参与者从一系列建筑场景图片中判断是否存在危险。我们计算并比较了两个经验水平组的 SDT 和记录的 EEG 信号的时频表示的敏感性和反应偏差。
新手工人的危险识别率更高。从行为角度来看,新手比经验丰富的工人更敏感。与经验丰富的工人相比,新手在危险识别过程中,左额区和右顶后区的伽马波段差异功率(危险与安全)更强。
新手在危险识别方面表现更好,这表明他们对危险的敏感性较高,而反应偏差没有明显差异。基于脑电图数据,新手的敏感性可能归因于更有效的工作记忆和注意力控制。
对于有安全干预需求的经验丰富的工人,需要不断更新危险识别技能。