Pérez-Martínez Vanesa, Sanz-Barbero Belén, Ferrer-Cascales Rosario, Bowes Nicola, Ayala Alba, Sánchez-SanSegundo Miriam, Albaladejo-Blázquez Natalia, Rosati Nicoletta, Neves Sofia, Vieira Cristina Pereira, Jankowiak Barbara, Jaskulska Sylwia, Waszyńska Katarzyna, Vives-Cases Carmen
Community Nursing, Preventive Medicine and Public Health and History of Science Department, University of Alicante, Alicante, Spain.
CIBER of Epidemiology and Public Health (CIBERESP), Madrid, Spain.
BMC Public Health. 2022 Mar 3;22(1):426. doi: 10.1186/s12889-022-12770-4.
Machismo and acceptance of violence (AV) against women are part of the social construction of hegemonic masculinity and are related to the risk of dating violence. This study aims to analyze the effectiveness of the Lights4Violence program in reducing machismo and AV in secondary school students from different European cities.
Quasi-experimental longitudinal study using a convenience sample of 1,146 high school students from different European cities (12-17 years old) including 575 intervention group students (59.1% girls) and 571 control group students (62.7% girls). We performed linear regression models to identify the effect of the intervention, modelling the difference in means in machismo and AV (dependent variables) between wave-2 and wave-1.
An interaction was identified between the group variable and the empathy variable. In wave-2, girls with high empathy at baseline in the intervention group obtained lower mean AV scores (β: -0.131; p = 0.004). However, the boys in the intervention group (reference: control group) with low empathy at baseline registered a significant increase in the mean values of machismo (β: 0.247; p < 0.001).
The importance of empathy is shown in the effectiveness of interventions to reduce machismo and AV in adolescents. While the Lights4Violence program focuses on promoting healthy relationships, there were some controversial results. It is possible that some children, especially those with less empathy, may have felt "challenged" during the intervention and/or assessment. This suggests the need for the development of interventions that also consider psychological processes and integrate the promotion of positive expressions of masculinity.
大男子主义以及对针对女性暴力行为的接受是霸权男性气质社会建构的一部分,并且与约会暴力风险相关。本研究旨在分析“反暴力之光”项目在减少来自不同欧洲城市的中学生的大男子主义和对针对女性暴力行为接受度方面的有效性。
采用准实验纵向研究,便利样本来自不同欧洲城市的1146名高中生(12 - 17岁),其中包括575名干预组学生(女生占59.1%)和571名对照组学生(女生占62.7%)。我们进行线性回归模型以确定干预效果,对第二波和第一波之间大男子主义和对针对女性暴力行为接受度(因变量)的均值差异进行建模。
在组变量和同理心变量之间发现了一种交互作用。在第二波中,干预组基线时具有高同理心的女孩获得了较低的平均对针对女性暴力行为接受度得分(β:-0.131;p = 0.004)。然而,干预组中基线时同理心低的男孩(参照:对照组)大男子主义均值有显著增加(β:0.247;p < 0.001)。
同理心的重要性在减少青少年大男子主义和对针对女性暴力行为接受度的干预效果中得以体现。虽然“反暴力之光”项目侧重于促进健康关系,但出现了一些有争议的结果。可能一些孩子,尤其是那些同理心较低的孩子,在干预和/或评估过程中可能感到“受到挑战”。这表明需要开发同时考虑心理过程并整合促进男性气质积极表达的干预措施。