Foley W D, Beres J, Smith D F, Bell R M, Milde M W, Lipchik E O
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1986 Sep;147(3):613-20. doi: 10.2214/ajr.147.3.613.
Temporal/energy (hybrid) subtraction is a technique for removing soft-tissue motion artifact from digital subtraction angiograms. The diagnostic utility of hybrid subtraction for i.v. and intraarterial angiography was assessed in the first 9 months of operation of a dedicated production system. In i.v. carotid arteriography (N = 127), hybrid subtraction (H) provided a double-profile projection of the carotid bifurcation in an additional 14% of studies, compared with temporal subtraction (T) alone (H79:T48, p less than 0.001). However, a change in estimated percent stenosis or additional diagnostic information occurred in only 2% of studies. In i.v. abdominal arteriography (N = 23), hybrid subtraction, compared with temporal subtraction, provided a diagnostic examination in an additional 14% of studies (H20:T17); however, this difference is not statistically significant. An additional three i.v. abdominal angiograms were nondiagnostic. In intraarterial abdominal (N = 98) and pelvic (N = 60) angiography, hybrid subtraction provided a diagnostic examination in an additional 5% of studies (abdomen H94:T90, pelvis H58:T56); this difference was not statistically significant. An additional 5% of all intraarterial abdominal and pelvic digital subtraction angiographic studies were considered nondiagnostic. Hybrid subtraction provides a double-profile view of the carotid bifurcation in a significant number of patients. However, apart from some potential for improved i.v. abdominal arteriography, hybrid subtraction does not result in significant improvement in comparison to conventional temporal-subtraction techniques.
时间/能量(混合)减影是一种从数字减影血管造影中去除软组织运动伪影的技术。在一个专用生产系统运行的前9个月,评估了混合减影在静脉内和动脉内血管造影中的诊断效用。在静脉内颈动脉造影(N = 127)中,与单独的时间减影(T)相比,混合减影(H)在另外14%的研究中提供了颈动脉分叉的双轮廓投影(H79:T48,p小于0.001)。然而,仅2%的研究中估计的狭窄百分比或额外的诊断信息发生了变化。在静脉内腹部动脉造影(N = 23)中,与时间减影相比,混合减影在另外14%的研究中提供了诊断性检查(H20:T17);然而,这种差异无统计学意义。另外有3例静脉内腹部血管造影未得出诊断结果。在动脉内腹部(N = 98)和盆腔(N = 60)血管造影中,混合减影在另外5%的研究中提供了诊断性检查(腹部H94:T90,盆腔H58:T56);这种差异无统计学意义。所有动脉内腹部和盆腔数字减影血管造影研究中另外有5%被认为未得出诊断结果。混合减影在相当数量的患者中提供了颈动脉分叉的双轮廓视图。然而,除了静脉内腹部动脉造影有一些潜在的改善外,与传统的时间减影技术相比,混合减影并没有带来显著改善。