Deli John, González-Beiras Camila, Guldan Georgia S, Moses Rachael L, Dally Jordanna, Moseley Ryan, Lundy Fionnuala T, Corbacho-Monne Marc, Walker Stephen L, Cazorla Maria Ubals, Ouchi Dan, Fang Rui, Briggs Marie, Kiapranis Robert, Yahimbu Martha, Mitjà Oriol, Prescott Thomas A K
Division of Public Health, School of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Papua New Guinea.
Fight AIDS and Infectious Diseases Foundation, Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain.
Phytomedicine. 2022 May;99:154026. doi: 10.1016/j.phymed.2022.154026. Epub 2022 Mar 4.
Infected cutaneous ulcers are major health problems for children living in rural areas of Papua New Guinea. The inaccessibility of affected populations and lack of access to basic healthcare, make a local plant-based therapy an attractive treatment option. We assessed Ficus septica exudate in biological assays relevant to wound healing. We then carried out a clinical trial to determine the exudate's efficacy in healing small cutaneous ulcers compared with Savlon antiseptic cream, and soap and water washing.
Pre-clinical in vitro assessment of the exudate was carried out using assays to monitor the pro-inflammatory responses of M1 macrophages and neutrophils, antibacterial assays using known ulcer pathogens, an Ames test for mutagenicity and LC-MS chemical analysis of the exudate. An open label cluster-randomised clinical trial was performed, enrolling participants from three different clusters with skin lesions less than 1 cm in diameter. Each cluster comprising 50 participants was randomly assigned to one of three treatment arms namely topical exudate, topical Savlon antiseptic cream, and standard care (soap and water treatment), all administered daily for 2 days. The primary outcome was clinical healing/improvement measured at days 7 and 14, assessed by three dermatologists using blinded photographs. The primary analysis was assessed as non-inferiority of F. septica treatment based on the risk difference for healing/improvement.
In vitro, the exudate which is rich in the alkaloid ficuseptine, was found to be non-mutagenic whilst also inhibiting pro-inflammatory responses and exhibiting antibacterial activity. When administered to participants enrolled in the clinical trial, no significant differences were observed between the healing efficacy of F. septica exudate and the two comparator treatments (Savlon antiseptic cream and soap/water treatment). At day 14, but not at day 7, the efficacy of F. septica exudate for healing/improving the ulcers was non-inferior to Savlon antiseptic cream or water/soap treatment.
F. septica exudate is non-mutagenic and has both bactericidal and anti-inflammatory properties. When applied topically to small cutaneous ulcers, the exudate has a healing effect that is non-inferior to Savlon antiseptic cream and standard treatment with soap and water at day 14. Our findings, which should be confirmed in larger clinical trials, have important public health implications.
感染性皮肤溃疡是巴布亚新几内亚农村地区儿童面临的主要健康问题。受影响人群难以获得医疗服务且缺乏基本医疗保健,使得基于当地植物的疗法成为一种有吸引力的治疗选择。我们在与伤口愈合相关的生物学试验中评估了琴叶榕渗出液。然后我们进行了一项临床试验,以确定与Savlon消毒乳膏以及用肥皂和水清洗相比,该渗出液在治疗小面积皮肤溃疡方面的疗效。
使用试验对渗出液进行临床前体外评估,以监测M1巨噬细胞和中性粒细胞的促炎反应,使用已知溃疡病原体进行抗菌试验,进行艾姆斯试验检测致突变性,并对渗出液进行液相色谱 - 质谱化学分析。开展了一项开放标签整群随机临床试验,招募来自三个不同群组、皮肤损伤直径小于1厘米的参与者。每个群组包含50名参与者,被随机分配到三个治疗组之一,即局部使用渗出液、局部使用Savlon消毒乳膏和标准护理(用肥皂和水处理),均每日给药2天。主要结局是在第7天和第14天测量的临床愈合/改善情况,由三名皮肤科医生使用盲法照片进行评估。基于愈合/改善的风险差异,主要分析评估琴叶榕治疗的非劣效性。
在体外,发现富含生物碱琴叶榕碱的渗出液无致突变性,同时还能抑制促炎反应并具有抗菌活性。当给予参与临床试验的参与者时,琴叶榕渗出液的愈合疗效与两种对照治疗(Savlon消毒乳膏和肥皂/水处理)之间未观察到显著差异。在第14天,但不是第7天,琴叶榕渗出液在愈合/改善溃疡方面的疗效不劣于Savlon消毒乳膏或水/肥皂治疗。
琴叶榕渗出液无致突变性,具有杀菌和抗炎特性。当局部应用于小面积皮肤溃疡时,该渗出液在第14天具有不劣于Savlon消毒乳膏和用肥皂和水进行标准治疗的愈合效果。我们的研究结果应在更大规模的临床试验中得到证实,具有重要的公共卫生意义。