Department of Pathology, University College of Medical Sciences and GTB hospital, New Delhi 110095, India.
Department of Pathology, University College of Medical Sciences and GTB hospital, New Delhi 110095, India.
Clin Breast Cancer. 2022 Jul;22(5):455-461. doi: 10.1016/j.clbc.2022.02.010. Epub 2022 Feb 23.
Both static images and videoconferencing by smartphone have been tried for telepathology. Combining the two approaches for telepathology might offset some of the limitations of both techniques.
A total of 150 cases of breast pathology were retrieved and were photographed by a trained junior pathologist using a smartphone camera and binocular microscope and the images were sent as Google photos attachments with email to three pathologists. The pathologists opened the emailed attachments during separate prescheduled google meet videoconferencing sessions and rendered the diagnosis verbally to the junior pathologist. The pathologists were given the option of asking for live dynamic images of the cases during the meet which were transmitted using the rear camera of the smartphone with the video option of google meet.
The overall concordance rates for the three pathologists were 96.6%, 99.3% and 98.0% (Mean 98.0%). The reporting pathologists asked for dynamic live images in 23, 20 and 18 cases respectively. Out of these 61 cases, a discrepant diagnosis was made in 7 cases (11.4%). The reporting pathologist was satisfied with the quality of static images (Mean Likert score 4.2/5). However, concerns were raised on the consistency of video quality (Mean Likert score 2.5/5). The screen share option of Google meet was found useful to discuss specific features of the case. (Mean Likert Score 4.6/5) CONCLUSION: The combined approach to telepathology has shown some promise and it is hoped that with adequate training the discordance can be reduced.
静态图像和智能手机视频会议都曾被用于远程病理学。将这两种方法结合起来用于远程病理学,可能会弥补这两种技术的一些局限性。
共检索了 150 例乳腺病理学病例,由一名经过培训的初级病理学家使用智能手机相机和双目显微镜进行拍摄,并将图像作为 Google 照片附件通过电子邮件发送给三位病理学家。病理学家在单独安排的 Google 会议视频会议期间打开电子邮件附件,并向初级病理学家口头做出诊断。病理学家可以选择在会议期间要求实时动态图像,如果需要,使用智能手机的后置摄像头和 Google 会议的视频功能传输动态图像。
三位病理学家的总体一致性率分别为 96.6%、99.3%和 98.0%(平均值为 98.0%)。报告病理学家分别在 23、20 和 18 例病例中要求实时动态图像。在这 61 例病例中,有 7 例(11.4%)做出了不同的诊断。报告病理学家对静态图像的质量表示满意(平均李克特评分 4.2/5)。然而,他们对视频质量的一致性表示担忧(平均李克特评分 2.5/5)。Google 会议的屏幕共享选项被发现对讨论病例的具体特征很有用(平均李克特评分 4.6/5)。
联合应用远程病理学方法显示出一定的前景,希望通过充分的培训,可以降低不相符的比例。