Karosanidze Irina, Kiladze Ushangi, Kirtadze Nino, Giorgadze Mikhail, Amashukeli Nana, Parulava Nino, Iluridze Neli, Kikabidze Nana, Gudavadze Nana, Gelashvili Lali, Koberidze Vazha, Gigashvili Eka, Jajanidze Natela, Latsabidze Naira, Mamageishvili Nato, Shengelia Ramaz, Hovhannisyan Areg, Panossian Alexander
National Family Medicine Training Centre, 57 M. Tsinamdzghvrishvili Str., Tbilisi 0102, Georgia.
Department for History of Medicine and Bioethics, Faculty of Medicine, Tbilisi State Medical University, Vazha-Pshavela Ave. 33, Tbilisi 0162, Georgia.
Pharmaceuticals (Basel). 2022 Mar 11;15(3):345. doi: 10.3390/ph15030345.
Currently, no effective treatment of comorbid complications or COVID-19 long-haulers during convalescence is known. This randomized, quadruple-blind, placebo-controlled trial aimed to assess the efficacy of adaptogens on the recovery of patients with Long COVID symptoms. One hundred patients with confirmed positive SARS-CoV-2 test, discharged from COVID Hotel isolation, Intensive Care Unit (ICU), or Online Clinics, and who experienced at least three of nine Long COVID symptoms (fatigue, headache, respiratory insufficiency, cognitive performance, mood disorders, loss of smell, taste, and hair, sweatiness, cough, pain in joints, muscles, and chest) in the 30 days before randomization were included in the study of the efficacy of Chisan/ADAPT-232 (a fixed combination of adaptogens Rhodiola, Eleutherococcus, and Schisandra) supplementation for two weeks. Chisan decreased the duration of fatigue and pain for one and two days, respectively, in 50% of patients. The number of patients with lack of fatigue and pain symptoms was significantly less in the Chisan treatment group than in the placebo group on Days 9 (39% vs. 57%, pain relief, = 0.0019) and 11 (28% vs. 43%, relief of fatigue, * = 0.0157). Significant relief of severity of all Long COVID symptoms over the time of treatment and the follow-up period was observed in both groups of patients, notably decreasing the level of anxiety and depression from mild and moderate to normal, as well as increasing cognitive performance in patients in the d2 test for attention and increasing their physical activity and workout (daily walk time). However, the significant difference between placebo and Chisan treatment was observed only with a workout (daily walk time) and relieving respiratory insufficiency (cough). A clinical assessment of blood markers of the inflammatory response (C-reactive protein) and blood coagulation (D-dimer) did not reveal any significant difference over time between treatment groups except significantly lower IL-6 in the Chisan treatment group. Furthermore, a significant difference between the placebo and Chisan treatment was observed for creatinine: Chisan significantly decreased blood creatinine compared to the placebo, suggesting prevention of renal failure progression in Long COVID. In this study, we, for the first time, demonstrate that adaptogens can increase physical performance in Long COVID and reduce the duration of fatigue and chronic pain. It also suggests that Chisan/ADAPT-232 might be useful for preventing the progression of renal failure associated with increasing creatinine.
目前,尚不清楚在康复期对合并症并发症或新冠长期症状者有何有效治疗方法。这项随机、四盲、安慰剂对照试验旨在评估适应原对新冠长期症状患者康复的疗效。100名经确诊的新冠病毒检测呈阳性患者被纳入奇散/ADAPT - 232(红景天、刺五加和五味子这几种适应原的固定组合)补充剂疗效研究,这些患者从新冠隔离酒店、重症监护病房(ICU)或线上诊所出院,且在随机分组前30天内出现了9种新冠长期症状中的至少3种(疲劳、头痛、呼吸功能不全、认知能力、情绪障碍、嗅觉丧失、味觉丧失、脱发、多汗、咳嗽、关节痛、肌肉痛和胸痛),接受为期两周的治疗。50%的患者服用奇散后,疲劳和疼痛持续时间分别缩短了1天和2天。在第9天(疼痛缓解,39%对57%,P = 0.0019)和第11天(疲劳缓解,28%对43%,P = 0.0157),奇散治疗组中无疲劳和疼痛症状的患者数量显著少于安慰剂组。两组患者在治疗及随访期间,所有新冠长期症状的严重程度均有显著缓解,尤其是焦虑和抑郁水平从轻度和中度降至正常,同时患者在注意力d2测试中的认知能力有所提高,身体活动和锻炼(每日步行时间)增加。然而,安慰剂组和奇散治疗组之间的显著差异仅体现在锻炼(每日步行时间)和缓解呼吸功能不全(咳嗽)方面。对炎症反应(C反应蛋白)和凝血(D - 二聚体)的血液标志物进行临床评估发现,除奇散治疗组白细胞介素 - 6显著较低外,各治疗组随时间推移未发现任何显著差异。此外,安慰剂组和奇散治疗组在肌酐方面存在显著差异:与安慰剂相比,奇散显著降低了血肌酐,这表明奇散可预防新冠长期患者肾衰竭的进展。在本研究中,我们首次证明适应原可提高新冠长期患者的身体机能,缩短疲劳和慢性疼痛的持续时间。这也表明奇散/ADAPT - 232可能有助于预防与肌酐升高相关的肾衰竭进展。