Korea Institute of Public Administration, Seoul, South Korea.
Program in Global Surgery and Implementation Science, JW LEE Center for Global Medicine, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Int J Health Plann Manage. 2022 Jul;37(4):2224-2239. doi: 10.1002/hpm.3463. Epub 2022 Mar 26.
Effective teamwork in paediatric cardiac surgery is known to improve team performance and surgical outcomes. However, teamwork in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), including Mongolia, is understudied. We examined multiple dimensions of teamwork to inform a team-based training programme to strengthen paediatric cardiac surgical care in Mongolia.
We used a mixed-methods approach, combining social network analysis and in-depth interviews with medical staff, to explore the structure, process, quality, and context of teamwork at a single medical centre. We conceptualised the team's structure based on communication frequency among the members (n = 24) and explored the process, quality, and context of teamwork via in-depth interviews with select medical staff (n = 9).
The team structure was highly dense and decentralised, but the intensive care unit nurses showed high betweenness-centrality. In the quality and process domain of teamwork, we did not find a regular joint decision-making process, leading to the absence of common goals among the team members. Although role assignment among the medical staff was explicit, those strictly defined roles hindered active communication about patient information and responsibility-sharing. Most interviewees did not agree with the organisational policies that limited discussions among team members; therefore, medical staff continued to share training and work experiences with each other, leading to strong and trustworthy relationships.
The findings of this study underscore the importance of well-structured and goal-oriented communication between medical staff, as well as the management of the quality of collaboration within a team to increase teamwork effectiveness in paediatric cardiac surgery teams in LMICs.
众所周知,在小儿心脏外科中,有效的团队合作可以提高团队绩效和手术结果。然而,包括蒙古在内的低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)的团队合作研究较少。我们考察了小儿心脏外科团队合作的多个维度,为蒙古的以团队为基础的培训计划提供信息,以加强小儿心脏外科护理。
我们使用混合方法,结合社会网络分析和对医务人员的深入访谈,来探索单一医疗中心的团队结构、过程、质量和背景。我们根据成员之间的沟通频率(n=24)来描述团队的结构,并通过对选定医务人员(n=9)的深入访谈来探讨团队合作的过程、质量和背景。
团队结构非常密集和分散,但重症监护室护士的中介中心度较高。在团队合作的质量和过程领域,我们没有发现定期的联合决策过程,导致团队成员之间没有共同目标。尽管医务人员之间的角色分配是明确的,但这些严格定义的角色阻碍了对患者信息和责任分担的积极沟通。大多数受访者不同意限制团队成员之间讨论的组织政策;因此,医务人员继续相互分享培训和工作经验,从而建立了强大而值得信赖的关系。
本研究结果强调了医务人员之间有良好结构和目标导向的沟通的重要性,以及管理团队合作质量以提高 LMICs 中小儿心脏外科团队的团队合作效果的重要性。