Hwang Mark C, Rozycki Martin, Kauffman David, Arndt Theresa, Yi Esther, Weisman Michael H
McGovern Medical School at The University of Texas Health Science Center, Houston.
HVH Precision Analytics, LLC, Wayne, Pennsylvania.
ACR Open Rheumatol. 2022 Jun;4(6):540-546. doi: 10.1002/acr2.11428. Epub 2022 Mar 29.
The study objective was to explore differences in ankylosing spondylitis (AS) diagnosis experiences between men and women by examining the coding of health events over the 2 years preceding AS diagnosis.
Claims data (January 2006-April 2019) from the MarketScan databases were examined. Patients who had received two or more AS diagnoses at least 30 days apart and had at least 2 years of insurance enrollment before their first AS diagnosis were analyzed. Men were matched 1:1 to women by age, diagnosis date, insurance type, and enrollment duration. Health events (diagnosis and provider codes) were examined over 2 years before AS diagnosis and stratified by gender. Data were analyzed using univariate χ tests.
Among 7744 patients, 274 of 1906 AS-related codes showed statistically significant differences between men and women. Women received more diagnosis codes than men across diagnoses and providers; the largest difference in diagnosis codes among women versus men was in peripheral symptom coding (57.7% vs. 43.9%, respectively). More women than men received diagnosis codes for depression (21.2% vs. 9.8%) and other musculoskeletal symptoms (52.8% vs. 40.0%); only gout was more common in men (6.5%) than in women (2.2%). Among men, backache codes gradually increased 12 months before AS diagnosis, whereas axial and sacroiliitis coding increased sharply immediately before diagnosis. The greatest difference in physician types visited was for rheumatologists: 64.2% of women had visits compared with 45.1% of men.
Further investigation into the dissimilarities in diagnostic experiences between men and women is needed to determine whether differences are due to disease phenotype or potential cognitive bias influencing diagnostic decision-making.
本研究的目的是通过检查强直性脊柱炎(AS)诊断前2年的健康事件编码,探讨男性和女性在AS诊断经历上的差异。
研究分析了MarketScan数据库中的索赔数据(2006年1月至2019年4月)。纳入分析的患者需满足至少相隔30天接受过两次或更多次AS诊断,且在首次AS诊断前至少有2年的保险参保记录。根据年龄、诊断日期、保险类型和参保时长,将男性与女性按1:1进行匹配。在AS诊断前2年对健康事件(诊断和医疗服务提供者编码)进行检查,并按性别分层。采用单因素χ检验进行数据分析。
在7744例患者中,1906个与AS相关的编码中有274个在男性和女性之间存在统计学显著差异。在所有诊断和医疗服务提供者中,女性收到的诊断编码比男性多;女性与男性之间诊断编码差异最大的是外周症状编码(分别为57.7%和43.9%)。女性比男性更多地收到抑郁症(21.2%对9.8%)和其他肌肉骨骼症状(52.8%对40.0%)的诊断编码;只有痛风在男性中(6.5%)比在女性中(2.2%)更常见。在男性中,背痛编码在AS诊断前12个月逐渐增加,而轴向和骶髂关节炎编码在诊断前立即急剧增加。就诊医生类型差异最大的是风湿病学家:64.2%的女性看过风湿病学家,而男性为45.1%。
需要进一步调查男性和女性诊断经历的差异,以确定这些差异是由于疾病表型还是潜在的认知偏差影响诊断决策。