Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Maskwacis Health Services, Maskwacis, Canada.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2022 Nov 30;18(5):2048558. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2022.2048558. Epub 2022 Mar 31.
To effectively support childhood vaccine programs for First Nations Peoples, Canada's largest population of Indigenous Peoples, it is essential to understand the context, processes, and structures organizing vaccine access and uptake. Rather than assuming that solutions lie in compliance with current regulations, our aim was to identify opportunities for innovation by exploring the work that nurses and parents must do to have children vaccinated. In partnership with a large First Nations community, we used an institutional ethnography approach that included observing vaccination clinic appointments, interviewing individuals involved in childhood vaccinations, and reviewing documented vaccination processes and regulations (texts). We found that the 'work' nurses engage in to deliver childhood vaccines is highly regulated by standardized texts that prioritize discourses of safety and efficiency. Within the setting of nursing practice in a First Nations community, these regulations do not always support the best interests of families. Nurses and parents are caught between the desire to vaccinate multiple children and the requirement to follow institutionally authorized processes. The success of the vaccination program, when measured solely by the number of children who follow the vaccine schedule, does not take into consideration the challenges nurses encounter in the clinic or the work parents do to get their children vaccinated. Exploring new ways of approaching the processes could lead to increased vaccination uptake and satisfaction for parents and nurses.
为了有效支持加拿大最大的原住民群体——第一民族人民的儿童疫苗接种计划,了解组织疫苗获取和接种的背景、流程和结构至关重要。我们的目标不是假设解决方案在于遵守现行规定,而是通过探索护士和家长必须做哪些工作才能让孩子接种疫苗,来寻找创新的机会。我们与一个大型的第一民族社区合作,采用了一种制度民族志方法,包括观察疫苗接种诊所预约、采访参与儿童疫苗接种的个人,以及审查记录的疫苗接种流程和规定(文本)。我们发现,护士在提供儿童疫苗接种时所从事的“工作”受到标准化文本的高度监管,这些文本优先考虑安全和效率的话语。在第一民族社区的护理实践环境中,这些规定并不总是符合家庭的最佳利益。护士和家长在想要为多个孩子接种疫苗和遵守机构授权流程之间左右为难。仅以遵循疫苗接种时间表的儿童数量来衡量,疫苗接种计划的成功并没有考虑到护士在诊所遇到的挑战,也没有考虑到家长为让孩子接种疫苗所做的工作。探索新的方法来处理这些流程可能会提高家长和护士对疫苗接种的满意度和接种率。