Alsulaiman Roaa, Harris John, Bamaas Sarah, Howell Peter
Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
Speech and Language Pathology Division, Jeddah Institute for Speech and Hearing, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Front Pediatr. 2022 Mar 11;10:750126. doi: 10.3389/fped.2022.750126. eCollection 2022.
Stuttering and other conditions that affect speech fluency need to be identified at an early age in order that effective interventions can be given before the problems becomes chronic. This applies in countries where several languages are spoken including those in which English and Arabic are both widely used which calls for assessment procedures that work across these languages. The 'universal' non-word repetition task (UNWR) has been established as an effective screening tool for discriminating between children who stutter (CWS) and children with word-finding difficulty for a number of languages. However, the UNWR does not apply to languages such as Arabic and Spanish. The present study aimed to: (1) introduce an Arabic English NWR (AEN_NWR); which was developed based on the same phonologically informed approach used with UNWR; (2) present preliminary non-word repetition data from Arabic-speaking CWS and adults who stutter (AWS). The AEN_NWR items comprises twenty-seven non-words that meet lexical phonology constraints across Arabic and English. The set of items includes non-words of two, three and four syllables in length. Preliminary non-word repetition data were collected from ten CWS between the ages of 6;5 and 16;7 ( = 12:1) and fourteen AWS between the ages of 19;2 and 31;0 ( = 24). Participants performed the non-word repetition task and provided a sample of spontaneous speech. The spontaneous speech samples were used to estimate %stuttered syllables (%SS). To validate that AEN_NWR performance provides an alternative way of assessing stuttering, a significant correlation was predicted between %SS and AEN_NWR performance. Also, word length should affect repetition accuracy of AEN_NWR. As predicted, there was a significant negative correlation between the AEN_NWR and %SS scores (r (25) = -0.5), < 0.000). Overall, CWS were less accurate in their repetition than AWS at all syllable lengths. The AEN_NWR provides a new assessment tool for detecting stuttering in speaker of Arabic and English. Future studies would benefit from a larger sample of participants, and by testing a population-based sample. These studies would allow further investigation of the AEN_NWR as a screening measure for stuttering in preschool children.
口吃及其他影响言语流畅性的病症需要在儿童早期就被识别出来,以便在问题变成慢性问题之前就能给予有效的干预措施。这在那些使用多种语言的国家适用,包括英语和阿拉伯语都被广泛使用的国家,这就需要能适用于这些语言的评估程序。“通用”非词重复任务(UNWR)已被确立为一种有效的筛查工具,可用于区分多种语言的口吃儿童(CWS)和存在找词困难的儿童。然而,UNWR并不适用于阿拉伯语和西班牙语等语言。本研究旨在:(1)引入一种阿拉伯语-英语非词重复任务(AEN_NWR);它是基于与UNWR相同的语音学方法开发的;(2)呈现来自说阿拉伯语的口吃儿童(CWS)和成年口吃者(AWS)的初步非词重复数据。AEN_NWR项目包括二十七个符合阿拉伯语和英语词汇语音学限制的非词。这组项目包括长度为两个、三个和四个音节的非词。从10名年龄在6岁5个月至16岁7个月(平均年龄 = 12岁1个月)的口吃儿童(CWS)和14名年龄在19岁2个月至31岁0个月(平均年龄 = 24岁)的成年口吃者(AWS)收集了初步非词重复数据。参与者完成非词重复任务并提供一份自发言语样本。自发言语样本用于估计口吃音节百分比(%SS)。为了验证AEN_NWR表现提供了一种评估口吃的替代方法,预计%SS与AEN_NWR表现之间存在显著相关性。此外,词长应会影响AEN_NWR的重复准确性。正如预期的那样,AEN_NWR与%SS分数之间存在显著负相关(r(25)= -0.5,p < 0.000)。总体而言,在所有音节长度上,口吃儿童(CWS)的重复准确性都低于成年口吃者(AWS)。AEN_NWR为检测说阿拉伯语和英语的人的口吃提供了一种新的评估工具。未来的研究将受益于更大规模的参与者样本,并通过测试基于人群的样本。这些研究将允许进一步研究AEN_NWR作为学龄前儿童口吃筛查措施的情况。