Contreras C, Amenábar T, Torres J, Jorge D, Rojas N, Pastrián L D, Silva F, Seguel D
Unidad de Cirugía de Cadera, Instituto Traumatológico Dr. Teodoro Gebauer, Santiago, Chile.
Unidad de Cirugía de Cadera, Instituto Traumatológico Dr. Teodoro Gebauer, Santiago, Chile.
Rev Esp Cir Ortop Traumatol. 2022 Mar-Apr;66(2):121-127. doi: 10.1016/j.recot.2021.07.004. Epub 2021 Nov 19.
Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is a condition which comprises a number of joint abnormalities, including modifications in femoral version and neck-shaft angle (CCD), as well as a probable progression to osteoarthritis in certain cases. The main objective of this research was to find a correlation between femoral version and severity of DDH in patients with advanced osteoarthritis prior to joint replacement, which has not been previously reported. A secondary aim was to describe the modification of CCD as the severity of DDH increases.
Patients over the age of 15 with dysplastic hips and severe osteoarthritis prior to total hip arthroplasty were assessed between March 2018 and February 2019. Cases with any previous hip surgery were excluded. Anteroposterior pelvis X rays and femoral computed tomography (CT) were performed; femoral version was measured in CT and CCD was evaluated both in X rays (2 observers: A and B) and CT (one observer: musculoskeletal radiologist). Severity of DDH was defined by observers A and B according to Crowe classification in X rays. Statistical analysis was performed on SPSS v.21. Shapiro-Wilk test was used to confirm a normal data distribution. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) determined the level of agreement between observers A and B. Pearson test assessed the correlation between femoral version and Crowe classification (positive if >0.5). Student's t test evaluated the statistical significance, which was defined as P<0.05.
One-year assessment; 42 patients (54 hips), 76% women. Mean age 52.7 years. 45 hips completed the imaging set, 9 hips were assessed only with X rays. 48%, 16%, 7% and 28% were classified as Crowe I, II, III and IV (100% interobserver agreement). Crowe classes were grouped as I, II/III and IV due to a low number of cases classified as II and III. Mean femoral version was 21.73°, 26.8° and 43.58°, respectively. ICC between observers A and B for CCD measured in X rays was 0.96. Mean CCD measured in X rays for each group (I, II/III and IV) was 148.11°, 147.7° and 147°, and in CT was 131.21°, 127.9° and 122.14°, respectively. A significant difference was found in femoral version between groups I and IV (P=0.0002) and II/III and IV (P=0.042). Pearson correlation between femoral version and severity of DDH was positive (r=0.52; P=0.0002). A significant difference between CCD measured in CT was found between groups I and IV (P=0.003).
A significant increase in femoral version related to severity of DDH and a positive correlation between these 2features were found. Furthermore, a significant decrease in CCD between groups I and IV measured in CT was revealed. These findings would be helpful for preoperative planning of total hip replacement in osteoarthritis secondary to DDH, because once the surgeon has assessed the severity of DDH on X rays or CT, an increased femoral version could be expected. Therefore, availability of specific implants such as conic, modular or cemented stems is critical, in order to modify the femoral anteversion to normal values in the most severe cases.
发育性髋关节发育不良(DDH)是一种包含多种关节异常的病症,包括股骨扭转和颈干角(CCD)的改变,在某些情况下还可能发展为骨关节炎。本研究的主要目的是找出关节置换术前晚期骨关节炎患者的股骨扭转与DDH严重程度之间的相关性,此前尚未有相关报道。次要目的是描述随着DDH严重程度增加CCD的变化情况。
2018年3月至2019年2月期间,对15岁以上髋关节发育不良且在全髋关节置换术前患有严重骨关节炎的患者进行了评估。排除既往有任何髋关节手术史的病例。拍摄骨盆前后位X线片和股骨计算机断层扫描(CT);在CT上测量股骨扭转,在X线片(两名观察者:A和B)和CT(一名观察者:肌肉骨骼放射科医生)上评估CCD。观察者A和B根据X线片上的Crowe分类定义DDH的严重程度。使用SPSS v.21进行统计分析。采用Shapiro-Wilk检验确认数据分布是否正常。组内相关系数(ICC)确定观察者A和B之间的一致性水平。Pearson检验评估股骨扭转与Crowe分类之间的相关性(若>0.5则为正相关)。采用学生t检验评估统计学意义,定义为P<0.05。
一年评估期;42例患者(54髋),76%为女性。平均年龄52.7岁。45髋完成了影像学检查,9髋仅进行了X线评估。48%、16%、7%和28%分别被分类为Crowe I、II、III和IV级(观察者间一致性为100%)。由于II级和III级病例数量较少,将Crowe分级合并为I级、II/III级和IV级。平均股骨扭转分别为21.73°、26.8°和43.58°。观察者A和B在X线片上测量的CCD的ICC为0.96。每组(I级、II/III级和IV级)在X线片上测量的平均CCD分别为148.11°、147.7°和147°,在CT上分别为131.21°、127.9°和122.14°。I级和IV级之间(P=0.0002)以及II/III级和IV级之间(P=0.042)的股骨扭转存在显著差异。股骨扭转与DDH严重程度之间的Pearson相关性为正(r=0.52;P=0.0002)。I级和IV级在CT上测量的CCD之间存在显著差异(P=0.003)。
发现股骨扭转与DDH严重程度显著增加相关,且这两个特征之间呈正相关。此外,还揭示了I级和IV级在CT上测量的CCD显著降低。这些发现将有助于DDH继发性骨关节炎全髋关节置换术的术前规划,因为一旦外科医生在X线片或CT上评估了DDH的严重程度,就可以预期股骨扭转会增加。因此,在最严重的病例中,提供如锥形、模块化或骨水泥柄等特定植入物以将股骨前倾角调整至正常值至关重要。