Papadopoulos Vasileios P, Emmanouilidou Anatoli, Yerou Marios, Panagaris Stefanos, Souleiman Chousein, Varela Despoina, Avramidou Peny, Melissopoulou Evangelia, Pappas Chrysostomos, Iliadou Zoi, Piperopoulos Ilias, Somadis Vasileios, Partsalidis Anestis, Metaxa Eleni, Feresiadis Ioannis, Filippou Dimitrios
Department of Internal Medicine, General Hospital of Xanthi, Xanthi, GRC.
Surgery, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, GRC.
Cureus. 2022 Mar 9;14(3):e22989. doi: 10.7759/cureus.22989. eCollection 2022 Mar.
Aim To investigate the reasons for disparity regarding the country-specific COVID-19-related case fatality rate (CFR) within the 30 countries of the European Economic Area (EEA). Materials and methods Data regarding population, area, COVID-19-associated infections/deaths, vaccination, life expectancy, elderly population, infant mortality, gender disparity, urbanization, gross domestic product (GDP), income per capita, health spending per capita, physicians, nursing personnel, hospital beds, ICU beds, hypertension, diabetes, obesity, and smoking from all EEA countries were collected from official sources on January 16, 2022. Correlation coefficients were computed, and optimal scaling using ridge regression was used to reach the most parsimonious multivariate model assessing any potential independent correlation of public health parameters with COVID-19 CFR. Results COVID-19 CFR ranges from 0.1% (Iceland) to 4.0% (Bulgaria). All parameters but population density, GDP, total health spending (% of GDP), ICU beds, diabetes, and obesity were correlated with COVID-19 CFR. In the most parsimonious multivariate model, elderly population rate (P = 0.018), males/total ratio (P = 0.013), nurses/hospital beds (P = 0.001), physicians/hospital beds (P = 0.026), public health spending (P = 0.013), smoking rate (P = 0.013), and unvaccinated population rate (P = 0.00005) were demonstrated to present independent correlation with COVID-19 CFR. In detail, the COVID-19 CFR is estimated to increase by 1.24 times in countries with vaccination rate of <0.34, 1.11 times in countries with an elderly population rate of ≥0.20, 1.14 times in countries with male ratio values ≥0.493, 1.12 times in countries spending <2,000$ annually per capita for public health, 1.14 and 1.10 times in countries with <2.30 nurses and <0.88 physicians per hospital bed, respectively, and 1.12 in countries with smoking ratio ≥0.22, while holding all other independent variables of the model constant. Conclusion COVID-19 CFR varies substantially among EEA countries and is independently linked with low vaccination rates, increased elderly population rate, diminished public health spending per capita, insufficient physicians and nursing personnel per hospital bed, and prevalent smoking habits. Therefore, public health authorities are awaited to consider these parameters in prioritizing actions to manage the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic.
目的 调查欧洲经济区(EEA)30个国家中特定国家新冠病毒相关病死率(CFR)存在差异的原因。材料与方法 2022年1月16日从官方来源收集了所有EEA国家的人口、面积、新冠病毒相关感染/死亡、疫苗接种、预期寿命、老年人口、婴儿死亡率、性别差异、城市化、国内生产总值(GDP)、人均收入、人均卫生支出、医生、护理人员、医院床位、重症监护病房床位、高血压、糖尿病、肥胖和吸烟等数据。计算相关系数,并使用岭回归进行最优尺度变换,以得出评估公共卫生参数与新冠病毒病死率之间任何潜在独立相关性的最简约多变量模型。结果 新冠病毒病死率范围从0.1%(冰岛)到4.0%(保加利亚)。除人口密度、GDP、卫生总支出(占GDP的百分比)、重症监护病房床位数量、糖尿病和肥胖外,所有参数均与新冠病毒病死率相关。在最简约多变量模型中,老年人口比例(P = 0.018)、男性/总人口比例(P = 0.013)、护士/医院床位数比例(P = 0.001)、医生/医院床位数比例(P = 0.026)、公共卫生支出(P = 0.013)、吸烟率(P = 0.013)和未接种疫苗人口比例(P = 0.00005)被证明与新冠病毒病死率存在独立相关性。详细而言,在疫苗接种率<0.34的国家,新冠病毒病死率估计增加1.24倍;在老年人口比例≥0.20的国家,增加1.11倍;在男性比例值≥0.493的国家,增加1.14倍;在人均每年公共卫生支出<2000美元的国家,增加1.12倍;在每医院床位护士<2.30名和医生<0.88名的国家,分别增加1.14倍和1.10倍;在吸烟率≥0.22的国家,增加1.12倍,同时保持模型的所有其他独立变量不变。结论 新冠病毒病死率在EEA国家之间存在显著差异,并且与低疫苗接种率、老年人口比例增加、人均公共卫生支出减少、每医院床位医生和护理人员不足以及普遍的吸烟习惯独立相关。因此,期待公共卫生当局在优先采取行动管理严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)大流行时考虑这些参数。