Department of Philosophy and Bioethics, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Michałowskiego 12, 31-126, Kraków, Poland.
Med Health Care Philos. 2022 Sep;25(3):383-393. doi: 10.1007/s11019-022-10085-0. Epub 2022 Apr 16.
The article aims at organizing multifaceted discourse on the concept of nondirectiveness in the practice of genetic counseling. The analysis of areas where nondirectiveness was invoked and discussed reveals the problematic confusion of different meanings of the term that often leads to false conclusions about the relations between the professional standards and the practice of genetic counseling. The article offers clear and comprehensive description of different approaches to nondirectiveness and various ideas associated with the term. Normative consequences of various meanings attributed to nondirectiveness are explored. The article concludes by presenting important but unsolved problems regarding both theory (the meaning of nondirectiveness and its operational definition) and practice of genetic counseling (the scope and content of the norm of nondirective counseling).
本文旨在对遗传咨询实践中非指导概念进行多方面的论述。对遗传咨询中援引和讨论非指导原则的领域进行分析,揭示了该术语不同含义之间存在的问题性混淆,这往往导致人们对专业标准与遗传咨询实践之间的关系产生错误的结论。本文对非指导原则的不同方法和与该术语相关的各种理念进行了清晰而全面的描述。探讨了归因于非指导原则的各种含义的规范性后果。本文最后提出了关于理论(非指导原则的含义及其操作定义)和遗传咨询实践(非指导咨询规范的范围和内容)的重要但未解决的问题。