Reinier van Arkel Mental Health Institute, The Netherlands, 's-Hertogenbosch.
Department of Developmental Psychology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
J Clin Psychol. 2022 Dec;78(12):2446-2455. doi: 10.1002/jclp.23361. Epub 2022 Apr 16.
Most psychotherapy outcome research focuses on symptom reduction as a primary outcome. However, most patients do not seek psychological treatment exclusively for symptom relief, but mainly because they can no longer do what they want to do or used to do. Therefore, besides symptom reduction, also disability in daily functioning should be a focus of psychotherapy outcome research. Yet, until now there is a paucity in research pertaining to the relation between symptom reduction and reduction of disability during psychological treatment.
For this reason, the aim of the current study was to examine the relationship between changes in symptom reduction (reduction in general symptom distress) and changes in self-reported disability over a period of two years in patients that receive psychotherapy for mood and anxiety disorders (N = 1182).
We found strong correlations between both outcome measures at all measurement points. Furthermore, results demonstrated a decrease in both outcome measures from start to end of treatment with a moderate effect for symptom distress and a small effect for experienced disability. Cross-lagged panel analysis demonstrated that a decrease in symptom distress predicted a subsequent decrease in self-reported disability, and a decrease in self-reported disability equally predicted a subsequent decrease in experienced symptom distress.
Our results seem to indicate that both outcome measures are interchangeable in psychotherapy outcome studies for internalizing disorders.
大多数心理治疗效果研究都将症状减轻作为主要结果。然而,大多数患者寻求心理治疗不仅仅是为了缓解症状,而是主要因为他们无法再做他们想做或过去常做的事情。因此,除了症状减轻,残疾在日常功能方面也应该成为心理治疗效果研究的重点。然而,到目前为止,关于心理治疗过程中症状减轻与残疾减轻之间关系的研究还很少。
出于这个原因,本研究的目的是在两年的时间内,检查患有情绪和焦虑障碍的患者接受心理治疗期间症状减轻(一般症状困扰减少)与自我报告残疾变化之间的关系(N=1182)。
我们发现,在所有测量点上,这两个结果测量之间都有很强的相关性。此外,结果表明,从治疗开始到结束,这两个结果测量都有所下降,症状困扰的下降程度为中度,而残疾的下降程度为轻度。交叉滞后面板分析表明,症状困扰的减轻预测了随后自我报告残疾的减轻,而自我报告残疾的减轻同样预测了随后经历的症状困扰的减轻。
我们的结果似乎表明,这两种结果测量在内部障碍的心理治疗效果研究中是可以互换的。