Rahman Ahmed Ehsanur, Jabeen Sabrina, Fernandes Genevie, Banik Goutom, Islam Jahurul, Ameen Shafiqul, Ashrafee Sabina, Hossain Aniqa Tasnim, Alam Husam Md Shah, Majid Tamanna, Saberin Ashfia, Ahmed Anisuddin, A N M Ehtesham Kabir, Chisti Mohammod Jobayer, Ahmed Sabbir, Khan Mahbuba, Jackson Tracy, Dockrell David H, Nair Harish, El Arifeen Shams, Islam Muhammad Shariful, Campbell Harry
NIHR Global Health Research Unit on Respiratory Health (RESPIRE), Usher Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
icddr,b (International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh), Dhaka, Bangladesh.
J Glob Health. 2022 Apr 9;12:06001. doi: 10.7189/jogh.12.06001. eCollection 2022.
Pneumonia is the leading cause of under-five child deaths globally and in Bangladesh. Hypoxaemia or low (<90%) oxygen concentration in the arterial blood is one of the strongest predictors of child mortality from pneumonia and other acute respiratory infections. Since 2014, the World Health Organization recommends using pulse oximetry devices in Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI) services (outpatient child health services), but it was not routinely used in most health facilities in Bangladesh until 2018. This paper describes the stakeholder engagement process embedded in an implementation research study to influence national policy and programmes to introduce pulse oximetry in routine IMCI services in Bangladesh.
Based on literature review and expert consultations, we developed a conceptual framework, which guided the planning and implementation of a 4-step stakeholder engagement process. Desk review, key informant interviews, consultative workshops and onsite demonstration were the key methods to involve and engage a wide range of stakeholders. In the first step, a comprehensive desk review and key informant interviews were conducted to identify stakeholder organisations and scored them based on their power and interest levels regarding IMCI implementation in Bangladesh. In the second step, two national level, two district level and five sub-district level sensitisation workshops were organised to orient all stakeholder organisations having high power or high interest regarding the importance of using pulse oximetry for pneumonia assessment and classification. In the third step, national and district level high power-high interest stakeholder organisations were involved in developing a joint action plan for introducing pulse oximetry in routine IMCI services. In the fourth step, led by a formal working group under the leadership of the Ministry of Health, we updated the national IMCI implementation package, including all guidelines, training manuals, services registers and referral forms in English and Bangla. Subsequently, we demonstrated its use in real-life settings involving various levels of (national, district and sub-district) stakeholders and worked alongside the government leaders towards carefully resuming activities despite the COVID-19 pandemic.
Our engagement process contributed to the national decision to introduce pulse oximetry in routine child health services and update the national IMCI implementation package demonstrating country ownership, government leadership and multi-partner involvement, which are steppingstones towards scalability and sustainability. However, our experience clearly delineates that stakeholder engagement is a context-driven, time-consuming, resource-intensive, iterative, mercurial process that demands meticulous planning, prioritisation, inclusiveness, and adaptability. It is also influenced by the expertise, experience and positionality of the facilitating organization.
Our experience has demonstrated the value and potential of the approach that we adopted for stakeholder engagement. However, the approach needs to be conceptualised coupled with the allocation of adequate resources and time commitment to implement it effectively.
肺炎是全球及孟加拉国五岁以下儿童死亡的主要原因。低氧血症或动脉血中氧浓度低(<90%)是儿童因肺炎和其他急性呼吸道感染死亡的最强预测因素之一。自2014年以来,世界卫生组织建议在儿童疾病综合管理(IMCI)服务(儿童门诊保健服务)中使用脉搏血氧仪,但直到2018年,孟加拉国大多数医疗机构都未常规使用。本文描述了一项实施研究中嵌入的利益相关者参与过程,以影响国家政策和计划,在孟加拉国的常规IMCI服务中引入脉搏血氧仪。
基于文献综述和专家咨询,我们制定了一个概念框架,指导了一个4步利益相关者参与过程的规划和实施。案头审查、关键信息提供者访谈、协商研讨会和现场示范是让广泛利益相关者参与的关键方法。第一步,进行了全面的案头审查和关键信息提供者访谈,以确定利益相关者组织,并根据它们对孟加拉国IMCI实施的权力和兴趣水平对其进行评分。第二步,组织了两次国家级、两次区级和五次乡级宣传研讨会,以使所有对使用脉搏血氧仪进行肺炎评估和分类的重要性有高权力或高兴趣的利益相关者组织了解情况。第三步,国家级和区级高权力-高兴趣利益相关者组织参与制定在常规IMCI服务中引入脉搏血氧仪的联合行动计划。第四步,在卫生部领导下的一个正式工作组的带领下,我们更新了国家IMCI实施包,包括所有英文和孟加拉文的指南、培训手册、服务登记册和转诊表格。随后,我们在涉及各级(国家、地区和乡级)利益相关者的实际环境中展示了其使用情况,并与政府领导人合作,尽管面临新冠疫情,仍谨慎地恢复了活动。
我们的参与过程促成了在常规儿童保健服务中引入脉搏血氧仪的国家决定,并更新了国家IMCI实施包,展示了国家自主权、政府领导和多伙伴参与,这些是实现可扩展性和可持续性的垫脚石。然而,我们的经验清楚地表明,利益相关者参与是一个受背景驱动、耗时、资源密集、反复无常的过程,需要精心规划、确定优先次序、包容各方并具备适应性。它还受到促进组织的专业知识、经验和立场的影响。
我们的经验证明了我们采用的利益相关者参与方法的价值和潜力。然而,该方法需要结合充足的资源分配和时间投入进行概念化,以有效实施。