Spatial preferences account for inter-animal variability during the continual learning of a dynamic cognitive task.

Understanding the complexities of behavior is necessary to interpret neurophysiological data and establish animal models of neuropsychiatric disease. This understanding requires knowledge of the underlying information-processing structure-something often hidden from direct observation. Commonly, one assumes that behavior is solely governed by the experimenter-controlled rules that determine tasks. For example, differences in tasks that require memory of past actions are often interpreted as exclusively resulting from differences in memory. However, such assumptions are seldom tested. Here, we provide a comprehensive examination of multiple processes that contribute to behavior in a prevalent experimental paradigm. Using a combination of behavioral automation, hypothesis-driven trial design, and reinforcement learning modeling, we show that rats learn a spatial alternation task consistent with their drawing upon spatial preferences in addition to memory. Our approach also distinguishes learning based on established preferences from generalization of task structure, providing further insights into learning dynamics.