Wu Jeng-Cheng, Tang Kung-Pei, Hsu Yi-Hsin Elsa, Yang Ya-Ting, Chu Jan-Show, Lin Yen-Kuang, Hou Wen-Hsuan
Department of Urology, Taipei Medical University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
Department of Urology, School of Medicine, College of Medicine, Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 Apr 20;22(1):296. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03330-w.
In 2013, Taiwan launched a curriculum reform-the 7-year undergraduate medical education program was shortened to 6 years. This study explored the evaluation results from students regarding the curriculum reform and investigated graduates' perceptions regarding the curriculum organization of the two academic training programs affected by this curricular reform.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted from May 14 to June 12, 2019. The 315 graduates from both the 7-year and 6-year curriculum programs in the same medical school in Taipei were invited to participate in this study. In total, 197 completed questionnaires were received, representing a response rate of 62.5%. The results of the principal component analysis confirmed the validity of the constructs employed in this self-administered questionnaire.
The t-test results yielded two main findings. First, the graduates from the 6-year program had significantly lower scores for preparedness for the upcoming postgraduate-year residency training than did their 7-year program counterparts. Additionally, the male graduates had significantly higher scores in terms of perceptions regarding curriculum organization and preparedness for postgraduate-year residency training than the female graduates. The results of stepwise regression also indicated that the sex difference was significantly correlated with graduates' readiness for their postgraduate-year residency training.
To avoid sex disparities in career development, a further investigation of female medical students' learning environment and conditions is necessary. In addition to the cross-sectional study of students' perceptions, further repeated measurements of the objective academic or clinical performance of graduates in clinical settings are desirable.
2013年,台湾启动了课程改革——本科医学教育7年制缩短为6年。本研究探讨了学生对课程改革的评价结果,并调查了受此次课程改革影响的两个学术培训项目毕业生对课程设置的看法。
于2019年5月14日至6月12日进行了一项横断面调查。邀请了台北同一所医学院7年制和6年制课程项目的315名毕业生参与本研究。共收到197份完整问卷,回复率为62.5%。主成分分析结果证实了这份自填式问卷中所采用结构的有效性。
t检验结果产生了两个主要发现。第一,6年制项目的毕业生在为即将到来的研究生阶段住院医师培训做准备方面的得分显著低于7年制项目的毕业生。此外,男性毕业生在课程设置看法和研究生阶段住院医师培训准备方面的得分显著高于女性毕业生。逐步回归结果还表明,性别差异与毕业生研究生阶段住院医师培训的准备情况显著相关。
为避免职业发展中的性别差异,有必要进一步调查女医学生的学习环境和条件。除了对学生看法进行横断面研究外,还需要对毕业生在临床环境中的客观学术或临床表现进行进一步的重复测量。