Kahan B D, Flechner S M, Lorber M I, Golden D, Conley S, Van Buren C T
Transplantation. 1987 Feb;43(2):197-204. doi: 10.1097/00007890-198702000-00007.
The therapeutic efficacy of cyclosporine (CsA) as an immunosuppressive agent was complemented by a modest, long-term incidence of toxic complications in 402 renal allograft recipients engrafted one to five years prior to analysis. The overall patient and graft survivals at one year were 97% and 84% (actual), and at five years 92% and 67% (actuarial). The immunosuppressive therapeutic index was excellent: only 12% of allografts were lost from rejection, with 5% of patients succumbing to infection. While infections were common, tending to emanate in the urinary tract or to be viral in etiology, they were generally mild and readily controlled. Only four patients displayed malignancies; none succumbed to this cause. The most common toxic complication was hypertrichosis, which was accentuated in pediatric patients. While tremors occurred in 20% of patients, primarily during the first three months, other neuroectodermal complications of parethesias, depression, somnolence, and seizures were rare. Hepatotoxicity, which was noted in 50% of patients, particularly recipients of cadaveric grafts, generally was first seen as a transaminase elevation, at least partially reversible by dose-reduction and abating by the third year. Associated disturbances of cholelithiasis and pancreatitis were occasionally observed. Nephrotoxicity was the only persistent, long-term complication. Hypertension occurred in 72% of patients during the first month, 36% in the second year, and about 15% thereafter. Hyperuricemia, which occurred in about 30% of recipients during the first two years, was occasionally associated with symptomatic gout. The mean serum creatinine level remained elevated throughout the follow-up period at 1.8-1.9 mg/dl, suggesting persistent, but nonprogressive, drug-induced renal injury. The present analysis documents the relative safety of CsA for long-term therapy, and highlights the need for new approaches to ameliorate drug-induced nephrotoxicity.
在分析前一至五年接受肾移植的402例患者中,环孢素(CsA)作为免疫抑制剂的治疗效果伴随着一定比例的长期毒性并发症。一年时患者和移植物的总体存活率分别为97%和84%(实际值),五年时为92%和67%(精算值)。免疫抑制治疗指数极佳:仅12%的移植物因排斥反应而丢失,5%的患者死于感染。虽然感染很常见,多发生于泌尿系统或由病毒引起,但一般症状较轻且易于控制。仅有4例患者出现恶性肿瘤,无一例因此死亡。最常见的毒性并发症是多毛症,在儿科患者中更为明显。20%的患者出现震颤,主要在前三个月,其他神经外胚层并发症如感觉异常、抑郁、嗜睡和癫痫则较为罕见。50%的患者出现肝毒性,尤其是尸体肾移植受者,通常首先表现为转氨酶升高,至少部分可通过减少剂量逆转,并在第三年减轻。偶尔观察到伴有胆石症和胰腺炎的相关紊乱。肾毒性是唯一持续存在的长期并发症。72%的患者在第一个月出现高血压,第二年为36%,此后约为15%。约30%的受者在头两年出现高尿酸血症,偶尔伴有症状性痛风。在整个随访期间,平均血清肌酐水平持续升高至1.8 - 1.9mg/dl,提示存在持续性但非进行性的药物性肾损伤。本分析证明了CsA长期治疗的相对安全性,并强调了需要新方法来改善药物性肾毒性。