Panagopoulos Dimitrios, Strantzalis Georgios, Gavra Maro, Boviatsis Efstathios, Korfias Stefanos
Neurosurgical Department, Pediatric Hospital of Athens, 45701 Athens, Greece.
1st University Neurosurgical Department, Medical School, University of Athens, Evangelismos University Hospital, Athens 10676, Greece.
Children (Basel). 2022 Apr 1;9(4):493. doi: 10.3390/children9040493.
Shunt over-drainage in patients harboring a ventriculoperitoneal shunt constitutes one of the most devastating, and difficult to manage, side effects associated with this operation. Siphoning is one of the most important contributing factors that predispose to this complication. Based on the fact that the predisposing pathophysiologic mechanism is considerably multiplicated, amelioration of that adverse condition is considerably difficult to achieve. A lot of evidence suggests that the widespread utilization of gravitational valves or antisiphon devices is of utmost importance, in order to minimize or even avoid the occurrence of such complications. The recent literature data highlight that gravity-related, long-lasting shunt over-drainage consists of a momentous factor that could be considered one of the main culprits of central shunt failure. A lot of efforts have been performed, in order to design effective means that are aimed at annihilating siphoning. Our tenet was the investigation of the usefulness of the incorporation of an extra apparatus in the shunt system, capable of eliminating the impact of the siphoning effect, based on the experience that was gained by their long-term use in our institution. A retrospective analysis was performed, based on the data that were derived from our institution’s database, centered on patients to which an ASD was incorporated into their initial shunt device between 2006 and 2021. A combination of clinical, surgical, radiological findings, along with the relevant demographic characteristics of the patients were collected and analyzed. We attempted to compare the rates of shunt dysfunction, attributed to occlusion of the ventricular catheter, in a group of patients, before and after the incorporation of an anti-siphon device to all of them. A total number of 120 patients who have already been shunted due to hydrocephalus of different etiologies, were managed with the insertion of an ASD. These devices were inserted at different anatomical locations, which were located peripherally to the initially inserted valvular mechanism. The data that were collected from a subpopulation of 17 of these patients were subjected to a separate statistical analysis because they underwent a disproportionately large number of operations (i.e., >10-lifetime shunt revisions). These patients were studied separately as their medical records were complicated. The analysis of our records revealed that the secondary implementation of an ASD resulted in a decrease of the 1-year and 5-year central catheter dysfunction rates in all of our patients when compared with the relevant obstruction rates at the same time points prior to ASD insertion. According to our data, and in concordance with a lot of current literature reports, an ASD may offer a significant reduction in the obstruction rates that is related to the ventricular catheter of the shunt. These data could only be considered preliminary and need to be confirmed with prospective studies. Nevertheless, this study could be considered capable of providing supportive evidence that chronic shunt over-drainage is a crucial factor in the pathophysiology of shunt malfunction. Apart from that, it could provide pilot data that could be reviewed in order to organize further clinical and laboratory studies, aiming toward the assessment of optimal shunt valve systems that, along with ASD, resist siphoning.
对于接受脑室腹腔分流术的患者而言,分流过度引流是该手术最具破坏性且最难处理的副作用之一。虹吸作用是导致这一并发症的最重要因素之一。鉴于诱发该并发症的病理生理机制相当复杂,改善这种不良状况非常困难。大量证据表明,广泛使用重力阀或防虹吸装置对于尽量减少甚至避免此类并发症的发生至关重要。近期文献数据表明,与重力相关的长期分流过度引流是一个重要因素,可被视为中央分流失败的主要原因之一。人们已做出诸多努力来设计有效的方法以消除虹吸作用。我们的宗旨是,基于在我们机构长期使用这些装置所获得的经验,研究在分流系统中加入额外装置以消除虹吸效应影响的实用性。我们基于从本机构数据库获取的数据进行了一项回顾性分析,研究对象为2006年至2021年间在初始分流装置中加入抗虹吸装置(ASD)的患者。收集并分析了临床、手术、放射学检查结果以及患者的相关人口统计学特征。我们试图比较一组患者在全部安装抗虹吸装置前后因脑室导管堵塞导致的分流功能障碍发生率。共有120例因不同病因脑积水而接受分流术的患者安装了ASD。这些装置安装在不同的解剖位置,均位于最初安装的瓣膜机制的外周。从其中17例患者的亚组收集的数据进行了单独的统计分析,因为他们接受的手术数量过多(即终生分流修正手术>10次)。由于这些患者的病历复杂,故对他们进行单独研究。我们对记录的分析显示,与ASD植入前相同时间点的相关堵塞率相比,二次植入ASD后所有患者1年和5年的中央导管功能障碍发生率均有所降低。根据我们的数据,并且与当前许多文献报告一致,ASD可能会显著降低与分流脑室导管相关的堵塞率。这些数据只能被视为初步数据,需要前瞻性研究加以证实。然而,本研究可被视为能够提供支持性证据,证明慢性分流过度引流是分流故障病理生理学中的一个关键因素。除此之外,它还能提供可被审视的试点数据,以便组织进一步的临床和实验室研究,旨在评估与ASD一起能抵抗虹吸作用的最佳分流阀系统。