Carioti Desiré, Stucchi Natale, Toneatto Carlo, Masia Marta Franca, Broccoli Martina, Carbonari Sara, Travellini Simona, Del Monte Milena, Riccioni Roberta, Marcelli Antonella, Vernice Mirta, Guasti Maria Teresa, Berlingeri Manuela
Department of Humanities, University of Urbino Carlo Bo, Urbino, Italy.
Department of Psychology, University of Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2022 Apr 7;13:783775. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.783775. eCollection 2022.
Rapid Automatized Naming (RAN) is considered a universal marker of developmental dyslexia (DD) and could also be helpful to identify a reading deficit in minority-language children (MLC), in which it may be hard to disentangle whether the reading difficulties are due to a learning disorder or a lower proficiency in the language of instruction. We tested reading and rapid naming skills in monolingual Good Readers (mGR), monolingual Poor Readers (mPR), and MLC, by using our new version of RAN, the RAN-Shapes, in 127 primary school students (from 3rd to 5th grade). In line with previous research, MLC showed, on average, lower reading performances as compared to mGR. However, the two groups performed similarly to the RAN-Shapes task. On the contrary, the mPR group underperformed both in the reading and the RAN tasks. Our findings suggest that reading difficulties and RAN performance can be dissociated in MLC; consequently, the performance at the RAN-Shapes may contribute to the identification of children at risk of a reading disorder without introducing any linguistic bias, when testing MLC.
快速自动命名(RAN)被认为是发育性阅读障碍(DD)的一个通用指标,对于识别少数族裔语言儿童(MLC)的阅读缺陷也可能有帮助,在这类儿童中,可能很难区分阅读困难是由于学习障碍还是在教学语言方面的熟练程度较低。我们使用新版的RAN即RAN-形状,对127名小学生(三年级至五年级)的单语优秀阅读者(mGR)、单语阅读能力差的学生(mPR)和少数族裔语言儿童进行了阅读和快速命名技能测试。与先前的研究一致,少数族裔语言儿童平均而言,与单语优秀阅读者相比阅读成绩较低。然而,这两组在RAN-形状任务中的表现相似。相反,阅读能力差的学生组在阅读和RAN任务中表现均不佳。我们的研究结果表明,少数族裔语言儿童的阅读困难和RAN表现可能是分离的;因此,在测试少数族裔语言儿童时,RAN-形状任务的表现可能有助于识别有阅读障碍风险的儿童,而不会引入任何语言偏见。