Public Health Sciences, Medical University of Southern Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA
College of Health Sciences, Ethiopia and Mekelle University, Mekelle, Tigray, Ethiopia.
BMJ Glob Health. 2022 Apr;7(4). doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2022-008475.
War destroys health facilities and displaces health workers. It has a devastating impact on population health, especially in vulnerable populations. We assess the geographical distribution of the impact of war on healthcare delivery by comparing the pre-November 2020 and the November to June 2021 status of health facilities in the Tigray region of Ethiopia. Data were collected from February 2021 to June 2021, during an active civil war and an imposed communication blackout in Tigray. Primary data were collected and verified by multiple sources. Data include information on health facility type, geocoding and health facility status (fully functional (FF), partially functional (PF), not functional, no communication). Only 3.6% of all health facilities (n=1007), 13.5% of all hospitals and health centres (n=266), and none of the health posts (n=741), are functional. Destruction varies by geographic location; only 3.3% in Western, 3.3% in South Eastern, 6.5% in North Western, 8% in Central, 14.6% in Southern, 16% in Eastern and 78.6% in Mekelle are FF. Only 9.7% of health centres, 43.8% of general hospitals and 21.7% of primary hospitals are FF. None of the health facilities are operating at prewar level even when classified as FF or PF due to lack of power and water or essential devices looted or destroyed, while they still continue operating. The war in Tigray has clearly had a direct and devastating impact on healthcare delivery. Restoration of the destroyed health facilities needs to be a priority agenda of the international community.
战争摧毁了医疗设施并使卫生工作者流离失所。它对人口健康造成了破坏性影响,尤其是在弱势群体中。我们通过比较 2020 年 11 月之前和 2021 年 11 月至 6 月期间埃塞俄比亚提格雷地区的卫生设施状况,评估战争对医疗保健服务的影响的地理分布。数据于 2021 年 2 月至 6 月期间在提格雷地区发生内战和通讯中断期间收集。主要数据由多个来源收集和验证。数据包括卫生设施类型、地理编码和卫生设施状况(完全运作 (FF)、部分运作 (PF)、不运作、无通讯)的信息。只有 3.6%的所有卫生设施(n=1007)、13.5%的所有医院和卫生中心(n=266)和没有一个卫生所(n=741)是运作的。破坏程度因地理位置而异;西部只有 3.3%、东南部只有 3.3%、西北部只有 6.5%、中部只有 8%、南部只有 14.6%、东部只有 16%和梅克莱只有 78.6%是 FF。只有 9.7%的卫生中心、43.8%的综合医院和 21.7%的初级医院是 FF。由于缺乏电力和水或基本设备被掠夺或破坏,即使被归类为 FF 或 PF,所有卫生设施都无法按照战前水平运作,尽管它们仍在继续运作。提格雷的战争显然对医疗保健服务产生了直接和破坏性的影响。国际社会需要将修复被摧毁的卫生设施作为优先议程。