Forgas L B, Gound S
J Periodontol. 1987 Mar;58(3):153-8. doi: 10.1902/jop.1987.58.3.153.
This study investigated the hypothesis that antiformin-citric acid chemical curettage combined with scaling and root planing (SRP/AF) would significantly reduce pathogenic bacteria of the periodontal pocket when compared to scaling and root planing alone (SRP). Ten patients with moderate periodontitis participated. Four pockets per patient, one in each posterior sextant, were chosen. Pocket depths, attachment levels, and gingival index (GI) were measured. Bacterial samples were examined under dark-field microscope for: (1) spirochetes, (2) motile rods, and (3) all others. A randomized four-sextant treatment design was used. One sextant received no treatment, a second received SRP, and the two remaining sextants received identical treatments of SRP/AF. Of these two sextants, one was sampled at baseline and 12 weeks only in order to serve as an additional control. The remaining sextants were sampled at 1, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Both SRP and SRP/AF significantly reduced the percentage of spirochetes and motile rods. A significant reduction in GI and pocket depths was also noted. Attachment level showed no significant change. Results of both treatment groups showed no significant differences among any of the parameters. A comparison of the two SRP/AF groups indicated no significant difference among clinical or bacterial parameters due to sampling.
与单纯的龈下刮治术和根面平整术(SRP)相比,次氯酸钠 - 柠檬酸化学清创联合龈下刮治术和根面平整术(SRP/AF)能显著减少牙周袋内的病原菌。10名中度牙周炎患者参与了研究。每位患者选取4个牙周袋,每个后牙象限各1个。测量牙周袋深度、附着水平和牙龈指数(GI)。在暗视野显微镜下检查细菌样本,观察:(1)螺旋体,(2)活动杆菌,以及(3)其他所有细菌。采用随机四象限治疗设计。一个象限不进行治疗,第二个象限接受SRP治疗,其余两个象限接受相同的SRP/AF治疗。在这两个接受SRP/AF治疗的象限中,其中一个仅在基线和12周时取样,作为额外对照。其余象限在第1、4、8和12周时取样。SRP和SRP/AF均显著降低了螺旋体和活动杆菌的百分比。GI和牙周袋深度也有显著降低。附着水平无显著变化。两个治疗组的结果在任何参数上均无显著差异。对两个SRP/AF组的比较表明,由于取样原因,临床或细菌学参数之间无显著差异。