Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada.
Bristol, England, United Kingdom.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2022 Jul;89:102354. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2022.102354. Epub 2022 Apr 27.
With increased access to smartphones, the selfie has gained immense popularity in the past decade. Selfie images could be a significant source of ante-mortem (AM) image data in cases where dental records are unavailable or considered insufficient. The application of 3D imaging and selfies has not been explored to its full potential in human dental identification. The present study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of using selfies as AM data and comparing with 3D post-mortem (PM) scans as an alternative to multiple 2D PM photographs in forensic dental identification. The study sample consisted of 18 selfies (12 matching and 6 non-matching) and 15 3D dental scans obtained from the study participants. The study sample was assessed by 6 experienced forensic odontologists (Raters) in two phases; Phase I-Visual comparison of 2D selfies to 3D scans and Phase II-2D selfies superimposed upon 3D scans. Each rater looked at 15 cases, and a total of 1620 comparisons were made by 6 raters (72 for the 12 matching cases and 1548 were for non-matching) and the opinions for each of the comparisons were analyzed. The results of the study show that use of the 3D superimposition method increased the certainty of the conclusions reached by the raters for the cases with correct matches. Furthermore, 94.2% of the 1548 non-matching comparisons were correctly excluded, compared with 77% for the 2D visual comparison method. The study demonstrated the applicability of this 3D method as a valuable tool in assisting the forensic odontologist with dental identification using selfies.
随着智能手机的普及,自拍在过去十年中变得非常流行。在无法获得或认为牙科记录不足的情况下,自拍图像可能是生前(AM)图像数据的重要来源。3D 成像和自拍的应用尚未在人类牙科鉴定中充分发挥其潜力。本研究旨在评估将自拍用作 AM 数据的可行性,并将其与 3D 死后(PM)扫描进行比较,作为法医牙科鉴定中替代多个 2D PM 照片的方法。研究样本由 18 张自拍(12 张匹配和 6 张不匹配)和 15 张从研究参与者中获得的 3D 牙齿扫描组成。研究样本由 6 名经验丰富的法医牙科学家(评估者)在两个阶段进行评估;第 I 阶段-将 2D 自拍与 3D 扫描进行视觉比较;第 II 阶段-将 2D 自拍叠加在 3D 扫描上。每位评估者查看了 15 个案例,总共由 6 位评估者进行了 1620 次比较(12 个匹配案例的 72 个和 1548 个不匹配案例),并对每次比较的意见进行了分析。研究结果表明,使用 3D 叠加方法增加了评估者对正确匹配案例得出结论的确定性。此外,与 2D 视觉比较方法的 77%相比,正确排除了 94.2%的 1548 次不匹配比较。该研究表明,这种 3D 方法作为一种有价值的工具,可用于协助法医牙科学家使用自拍进行牙科鉴定。