Centre of Forensic and Legal Medicine and Dentistry, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
Centre of Forensic and Legal Medicine and Dentistry, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2022 Jan;85:102293. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2021.102293. Epub 2021 Nov 29.
The comparison of post-mortem evidence to ante-mortem data is the usual approach Forensic Odontologists take in managing human identification cases. Although dental charts and radiographs are widely used as ante-mortem dental evidence, photographs, including non-clinical ones such as selfies are not regarded as such. Therefore, photographs are not regularly assessed in identifying the deceased. This cross-sectional study was aimed to investigate the possible contributions of selfies in human identification and to suggest a structured methodology to assess selfie images with the data collected.
An e-survey composed of five open and seven close-ended questions was designed using JISC Online Surveys program (2020) to explore the opinions of practising Forensic Odontologists and related professionals on the use of photographs and selfies in human identification. Responses to the survey were collected and analysed into descriptive charts and statistics.
Eighty-two out of 200 professionals completed their responses (40.8% response rate). 73.2% of them acknowledged that selfies could be used as a main or adjunct evidence in dental identification. Experienced participants in selfies assessed dental anatomy (n = 6), dental restorations (n = 6), craniofacial landmarks (n = 5), oral soft tissues (n = 3), and implement the use of photo-editing software (n = 3) when provided with photographs to analyze using the direct comparison technique.
It may be concluded that selfies could be supplementary dental ante-mortem evidence. The designing of a step-by-step visual analysis of dental characteristics on a selfie photograph could subsequently be incorporated into official Forensic Odontology association guidelines worldwide. Further research in this area should be carried out along with the advancements in technology.
在处理人类识别案件时,法医牙科学者通常会将尸检证据与生前数据进行比较。尽管牙科图表和射线照片被广泛用作生前牙科证据,但照片(包括自拍等非临床照片)却不被视为此类证据。因此,在识别死者时,通常不会对照片进行评估。本横断面研究旨在探讨自拍在人类识别中的可能贡献,并提出一种评估自拍图像的结构化方法,该方法利用收集到的数据。
使用 JISC Online Surveys 程序(2020 年)设计了一个包含五个开放式和七个封闭式问题的电子调查,以探讨执业法医牙科学者和相关专业人员对在人类识别中使用照片和自拍的看法。收集对调查的回复,并将其分析为描述性图表和统计数据。
在 200 名专业人员中,有 82 人完成了回复(响应率为 40.8%)。他们中有 73.2%的人承认自拍可以用作牙科识别的主要或辅助证据。有自拍经验的参与者在提供照片以使用直接比较技术进行分析时,评估了牙齿解剖结构(n=6)、牙齿修复体(n=6)、颅面标志(n=5)、口腔软组织(n=3)和实施照片编辑软件的使用(n=3)。
可以得出结论,自拍可能是补充性的生前牙科证据。可以随后将对自拍照片上牙齿特征的逐步视觉分析设计纳入全球法医牙科学协会的官方指南中。应在该领域开展进一步的研究,并结合技术的进步。