Reducing surgical site infections after colectomy: bundle item compliance, process, and outlier identification.

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to implement a checklist monitoring system and identify critical surgical checklist items associated with post-colectomy surgical site infections (SSI). The relationship between checklist compliance, infection rates, and identification of non-compliant surgeons was explored.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

National Health Safety Network (NHSN) data were imported annually to establish baseline incidence of post-colectomy SSI from 2016 to 2019. A colectomy checklist was used to monitor compliance for 1694 random colectomies (1274 elective; 420 emergency). Reports were generated monthly to profile system, hospital, surgeon-specific infection, and checklist compliance rates.

RESULTS

Checklist compliance improved in elective and emergent colectomies to > 90% for all items except oral antibiotic and mechanical bowel prep in elective cases. Annualized total SSI and organ space infection rates in elective cases decreased by 33% and 45%, respectively. Elective and emergency SSI's were reduced for Superficial Incisional Primary (SIP), Deep Incisional Primary (DIP), and Intra-Abdominal Abscess (IAB) by 66%, 60.4%, and 78.3%, respectively. Checklist compliance between low (< 3%) and high (> 3%) infection rate surgeons demonstrated significantly lower utilization of oral antibiotic prep (p < 0.03) and mechanical bowel prep (p < 0.02) in high infection rate surgeons.

CONCLUSION

Surgeons compliant with colectomy checklists decreased elective and emergency colectomy infection rates. Ceiling compliance rates > 95% for bundle items are suggested to achieve optimal reductions in SSIs and efforts should be focused on surgeons with NHSN infection rates > 3%. Oral antibiotic prep and mechanical bowel prep compliance rates in elective colectomy appeared to differentiate high infection rate surgeons from low infection rate surgeons.