Virginia Tech, Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA.
Department of Forestry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, USA.
Ecol Appl. 2022 Oct;32(7):e2646. doi: 10.1002/eap.2646. Epub 2022 Jun 16.
Estimating tree leaf biomass can be challenging in applications where predictions for multiple tree species is required. This is especially evident where there is limited or no data available for some of the species of interest. Here we use an extensive national database of observations (61 species, 3628 trees) and formulate models of varying complexity, ranging from a simple model with diameter at breast height (DBH) as the only predictor to more complex models with up to 8 predictors (DBH, leaf longevity, live crown ratio, wood specific gravity, shade tolerance, mean annual temperature, and mean annual precipitation), to estimate tree leaf biomass for any species across the continental United States. The most complex with all eight predictors was the best and explained 74%-86% of the variation in leaf mass. Consideration was given to the difficulty of measuring all of these predictor variables for model application, but many are easily obtained or already widely collected. Because most of the model variables are independent of species and key species-level variables are available from published values, our results show that leaf biomass can be estimated for new species not included in the data used to fit the model. The latter assertion was evaluated using a novel "leave-one-species-out" cross-validation approach, which showed that our chosen model performs similarly for species used to calibrate the model, as well as those not used to develop it. The models exhibited a strong bias toward overestimation for a relatively small subset of the trees. Despite these limitations, the models presented here can provide leaf biomass estimates for multiple species over large spatial scales and can be applied to new species or species with limited leaf biomass data available.
估算树木叶片生物量在需要预测多个树种的应用中具有挑战性。在某些感兴趣的物种缺乏或没有数据的情况下,这一点尤为明显。在这里,我们使用了一个广泛的国家观测数据库(61 个物种,3628 棵树),并制定了不同复杂程度的模型,从仅以胸径(DBH)为唯一预测因子的简单模型到最多 8 个预测因子(DBH、叶片寿命、活冠比、木材比重、耐荫性、年平均温度和年平均降水量)的复杂模型,以估算整个美国大陆任何物种的树木叶片生物量。最复杂的模型包含所有 8 个预测因子,效果最好,可解释叶片质量变化的 74%-86%。在考虑模型应用中测量所有这些预测变量的难度时,许多变量很容易获得或已经广泛收集。由于模型的大多数变量与物种无关,并且关键的物种级变量可以从已发表的值中获得,因此我们的结果表明,可以估算未包含在用于拟合模型的数据中的新物种的叶片生物量。后者通过一种新颖的“逐个物种剔除”交叉验证方法进行了评估,该方法表明,我们选择的模型对于用于校准模型的物种以及未用于开发模型的物种的表现相似。这些模型对树木的一个相对较小子集表现出强烈的高估偏差。尽管存在这些局限性,但这里提出的模型可以在较大的空间尺度上为多个物种提供叶片生物量估计值,并可应用于新物种或叶片生物量数据有限的物种。