Nossal Institute for Global Health, The University of Melbourne, 333 Exhibition St. Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
District Health Office, Sikka Regency, East Nusa Tenggara Province, Indonesia.
Midwifery. 2022 Jul;110:103318. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2022.103318. Epub 2022 Mar 30.
This study examined routine newborn care practices provided in the postnatal ward of primary health care facilities, known as Puskesmas, in Sikka District of eastern Indonesia The newborn mortality rate in this region is higher than the national rate despite an increasing proportion of facility based births, suggesting suboptimal quality of newborn care.
We employed a mixed methods study combining qualitative and quantitative approaches, in four purposively sampled Puskesmas. Nine mothers, twelve midwives, and four key informants were interviewed on the provision and experience of postnatal care, and an audit of postnatal care processes, including observation of routine postnatal check-up was conducted. The data were analyzed using framework analysis and standard descriptive statistics.
Despite appropriate regulation, national guidance on postnatal care and adequate financing that supported continuity of supplies and equipment, postnatal care practices, including counselling around newborn danger signs, did not meet the national guidelines in any of the Puskesmas in this study. Postnatal care was a low priority, the responsibility often given to new graduates on voluntary placements with little job security, who were insufficiently trained or supervised. In addition, inadequate water and sanitation in postnatal care wards deterred women from staying for the recommended postnatal observation period.
Despite strong support for postnatal care at the policy level, at the implementation level postnatal newborn care is not prioritised by midwives. Under-functioning infrastructure and inadequate planning and budgeting for postnatal check-ups are major challenges to the provision of care in the postnatal wards.
本研究考察了印度尼西亚东部锡卡地区初级卫生保健机构(Puskesmas)产后病房提供的常规新生儿护理实践。尽管越来越多的分娩选择在医疗机构进行,但该地区的新生儿死亡率仍高于全国平均水平,这表明新生儿护理质量不尽人意。
我们采用了混合方法研究,结合了定性和定量方法,在四个有针对性选择的 Puskesmas 进行。对 9 名母亲、12 名助产士和 4 名关键信息提供者进行了关于产后护理的提供和体验的访谈,并对产后护理流程进行了审核,包括对常规产后检查的观察。使用框架分析和标准描述性统计对数据进行了分析。
尽管有适当的监管、国家关于产后护理的指导以及充足的资金支持,以确保供应和设备的连续性,但在本研究中的任何一个 Puskesmas,包括围绕新生儿危险信号的咨询,产后护理实践都不符合国家指南。产后护理是一个低优先级,通常由没有足够工作保障的自愿实习的新毕业生负责,他们的培训或监督不足。此外,产后病房的供水和卫生条件不足,阻止了妇女按照建议的产后观察期停留。
尽管在政策层面上对产后护理提供了强有力的支持,但在实施层面上,助产士并没有将产后新生儿护理作为优先事项。基础设施运行不良以及对产后检查的规划和预算不足,是产后病房提供护理的主要挑战。