Garweg G, Herrmann W M, Kern U
Z Gerontol. 1987 Jan-Feb;20(1):56-62.
A placebo-controlled, randomized double-blind study conducted at a general practitioner's surgery was designed to investigate the efficacy of bencyclane in 120 outpatients with cerebral dysfunctions based on organic brain syndrome. The study started with a 4-week placebo washout phase and then continued with a 12-week treatment phase. 200 mg Bencyclane-hydrogenfumarate was administered b.i.d. Efficacy was assessed by a doctor's symptom rating (SCAG) and a study nurse's rating (BGP) as well as by two performance tests (CFF and ZVT-G). Data from 106 patients (52 under bencyclane and 54 under placebo) were statistically analysed. More side effects were seen under bencyclane than under placebo, in particular insomnia, headache, akathisia, nausea and vomiting. As an a priori hypothesis, it was stated that after alpha-adjustment there should be a statistically significant difference in symptomatology (SCAG, BGP) and performance (CFF, ZVT-G). With regard to performance, the zero hypothesis could be rejected on the 5% level, and on the 1% level with respect to symptomatology. The experimental error on both the performance and the symptom level was below 6%. The drug effects were significant on a confirmatory level and are considered to be also of clinical relevance.
在一家普通科医生诊所进行了一项安慰剂对照、随机双盲研究,旨在调查苄环烷对120名基于器质性脑综合征的脑功能障碍门诊患者的疗效。研究开始时有一个为期4周的安慰剂洗脱期,然后是一个为期12周的治疗期。每日两次给予200毫克富马酸氢苄环烷。通过医生的症状评分(SCAG)、研究护士的评分(BGP)以及两项性能测试(CFF和ZVT-G)评估疗效。对106名患者(52名服用苄环烷,54名服用安慰剂)的数据进行了统计分析。与安慰剂相比,苄环烷组出现的副作用更多,尤其是失眠、头痛、静坐不能、恶心和呕吐。作为一个先验假设,有人指出,在进行α调整后,症状学(SCAG、BGP)和性能(CFF、ZVT-G)方面应该存在统计学上的显著差异。在性能方面,原假设在5%的水平上可以被拒绝,在症状学方面在1%的水平上可以被拒绝。性能和症状水平上的实验误差均低于6%。药物效果在验证水平上具有显著性,并且被认为也具有临床相关性。