Lee Edward A
Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA, United States.
Front Psychol. 2022 Apr 25;13:761808. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.761808. eCollection 2022.
"Rationality" in Simon's "bounded rationality" is the principle that humans make decisions on the basis of step-by-step (algorithmic) reasoning using systematic rules of logic to maximize utility. "Bounded rationality" is the observation that the ability of a human brain to handle algorithmic complexity and large quantities of data is limited. Bounded rationality, in other words, treats a decision maker as a machine carrying out computations with limited resources. Under the principle of embodied cognition, a cognitive mind is an machine. Turing-Church computations are not interactive, and interactive machines can accomplish things that no Turing-Church computation can accomplish. Hence, if "rationality" is computation, and "bounded rationality" is computation with limited complexity, then "embodied bounded rationality" is both more limited than computation and more powerful. By embracing interaction, embodied bounded rationality can accomplish things that Turing-Church computation alone cannot. Deep neural networks, which have led to a revolution in artificial intelligence, are both interactive and not fundamentally algorithmic. Hence, their ability to mimic some cognitive capabilities far better than prior algorithmic techniques based on symbol manipulation provides empirical evidence for the principle of embodied bounded rationality.
西蒙“有限理性”中的“理性”是指人类基于逐步(算法式)推理,运用系统逻辑规则来做出决策,以实现效用最大化的原则。“有限理性”是指观察到人类大脑处理算法复杂性和大量数据的能力是有限的。换句话说,有限理性将决策者视为一台资源有限的进行计算的机器。在具身认知原则下,认知思维是一台机器。图灵 - 丘奇计算不是交互式的,而交互式机器能够完成任何图灵 - 丘奇计算都无法完成的事情。因此,如果“理性”是计算,“有限理性”是具有有限复杂性的计算,那么“具身有限理性”既比计算更受限,又比计算更强大。通过接受交互,具身有限理性能够完成仅靠图灵 - 丘奇计算无法完成的事情。引发了人工智能革命的深度神经网络既是交互式的,又从根本上不是算法式的。因此,它们比基于符号操作的先前算法技术能更好地模拟某些认知能力,这为具身有限理性原则提供了经验证据。