Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
National Center for Electron Microscopy, Molecular Foundry, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
Science. 2022 May 13;376(6594):eabo5247. doi: 10.1126/science.abo5247.
We address the three main points of Guo . They claim that we should have used the engineering stress versus engineering strain curves to infer the mechanical properties of our nanotwinned titanium, question our sample design on the basis of a finite-element analysis, and doubt the immobility of some preexisting grain/twin boundaries in our electron backscatter diffraction micrographs. We find their analysis to be groundless and to contain many inconsistencies.
我们回应了郭等人提出的三个主要观点。他们声称,我们应该使用工程应力与工程应变曲线来推断我们的纳米孪晶钛的力学性能,基于有限元分析对我们的样品设计提出质疑,并怀疑我们的电子背散射衍射显微照片中某些预先存在的晶界/孪晶界的不可动性。我们发现他们的分析毫无根据,并且存在许多不一致之处。