Department of Epidemiology and Population Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, The American University of Beirut, Beirut P.O. Box 11-0236, Lebanon.
British Columbia Injury Research and Prevention Unit, British Columbia Children's Hospital Research Institute, Vancouver, BC V6H 3V4, Canada.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Apr 29;19(9):5434. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19095434.
Globally, residential fires constitute a substantial public health problem, causing major fire-related injury morbidity and mortality. This review examined the literature on residential fire prevention interventions relevant to Indigenous communities and assessed their effectiveness on mitigating fire incidents and their associated human and economic burden. Electronic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL, and Web of Science Core Collection were reviewed for studies on fire prevention interventions published after 1990 and based on the 4E's of injury prevention approaches (Education, Enforcement, Engineering, and Engagement). The grey literature and sources including indigenous organizational websites were also searched for eligible studies. Two authors independently screened, selected, and extracted data, in consultation with experts in the field. Outcomes measured included enhanced safety knowledge and practices, decreased residential fires incidents, reduced fire-related injuries and deaths, and lowered costs for healthcare needs. After removing duplicates, screening titles and abstracts, and assessing full texts, 81 articles were included in this review. Of the included studies, 29.1% implemented educational interventions within a variety of settings, including schools, community centres and homes, and included healthcare professionals and firefighters to raise awareness and the acquisition of fire safety skills. Engineering and environmental modifications were adopted in 20.2% of the studies with increased smoke alarm installations being the leading effective intervention followed by sprinkler inspections. Moreover, engagement of household members in hands-on safety training proved to be effective in enhancing household knowledge, fire safety decisions and practices. More importantly, effective outcomes were obtained when multi-faceted fire safety interventions were adopted, e.g., environmental modification and educational interventions, which together markedly reduced fire incidents and associated injuries. This review reveals the dearth of fire prevention evidence gathered directly within Indigenous communities. Nonetheless, relevant fire prevention recommendations can be made, calling for the adoption of combined and context-sensitive fire prevention interventions tailored to targeted Indigenous and vulnerable communities through multiple approaches and measures. Follow-ups and longitudinal studies are critical for accurate evaluation of the long-term outcomes and impacts on preventing residential fires.
全球范围内,住宅火灾是一个严重的公共卫生问题,导致了重大火灾相关伤害发病率和死亡率。本综述调查了与原住民社区相关的住宅火灾预防干预措施的文献,并评估了它们在减轻火灾事件及其相关人员和经济负担方面的有效性。使用 MEDLINE、EMBASE、CENTRAL 和 Web of Science 核心合集等电子数据库,检索了 1990 年后发表的、基于伤害预防方法的 4E 原则(教育、执法、工程和参与)的火灾预防干预措施研究。还搜索了灰色文献和包括原住民组织网站在内的其他来源,以寻找符合条件的研究。两名作者独立筛选、选择和提取数据,并与该领域的专家进行了协商。测量的结果包括提高安全知识和实践、减少住宅火灾事件、降低火灾相关伤害和死亡以及降低医疗保健需求的成本。在去除重复项、筛选标题和摘要以及评估全文后,本综述共纳入 81 篇文章。在纳入的研究中,29.1%在各种环境中实施了教育干预措施,包括学校、社区中心和家庭,并包括医疗保健专业人员和消防员,以提高认识和获取消防安全技能。20.2%的研究采用了工程和环境改造,增加烟雾报警器安装是最有效的干预措施,其次是喷水灭火系统检查。此外,让家庭成员参与实际的安全培训证明可以有效地提高家庭的知识、消防安全决策和实践。更重要的是,当采用多方面的消防安全干预措施时,如环境改造和教育干预措施,可显著减少火灾事件和相关伤害,从而获得有效的结果。本综述揭示了在原住民社区直接收集的火灾预防证据不足。尽管如此,仍然可以提出相关的火灾预防建议,呼吁通过多种方法和措施,针对目标原住民和弱势群体社区,采用综合和敏感的火灾预防干预措施。后续和纵向研究对于准确评估长期结果以及预防住宅火灾的影响至关重要。