Faculty of Dentistry, University, of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Oral Health Centre of Expertise, Rogaland, Stavanger, Norway.
Eur J Oral Sci. 2022 Aug;130(4):e12872. doi: 10.1111/eos.12872. Epub 2022 May 15.
In an earlier randomized controlled trial of dental anxiety treatments (n = 96) we compared the effects of dentist-administered cognitive behavioural therapy (D-CBT) and dental treatment supplemented with the Four Habits communication model plus midazolam sedation. Both treatments, applied in a general dental practice, were associated with a clinically relevant decrease in dental anxiety. In this follow-up study, 52 of the 82 treatment completers responded to an online questionnaire 1 year post-treatment. Reduction in dental anxiety persisted for both treatment groups. From baseline to 1 year post-treatment the Modified Dental Anxiety Scale was reduced by 7.8 [SD: 4.4; Cohen's d effect size: 1.2 (CI: 0.8-1.7)] and 7.8 [SD: 4.2; Cohen's d: 1.4 (0.9-1.8)] in the D-CBT and Four Habits/midazolam groups, respectively. Most patients (74% for D-CBT, 80% for Four Habits/midazolam) continued with dental treatment. Nine patients in the D-CBT and seven in the Four Habits/midazolam groups received additional CBT treatment from a psychologist/dentist team. Both methods tested should be accessible to interested dentists who receive adequate training. Effective first-line treatments for dental anxiety in general dental practice can generate more accessible care pathways for patients with dental anxiety. Evidence-based dental anxiety treatment programmes should be included in the dental curriculum and established as best practice for dentists.
在一项早期的牙科焦虑症治疗的随机对照试验(n=96)中,我们比较了牙医实施的认知行为疗法(D-CBT)和在牙科治疗中补充四习惯沟通模式加咪达唑仑镇静的效果。这两种治疗方法均在常规牙科诊所实施,均与牙科焦虑症的临床相关下降相关。在这项随访研究中,82 名治疗完成者中的 52 名在治疗后 1 年通过在线问卷做出了回应。两组治疗均持续降低牙科焦虑。从基线到治疗后 1 年,改良牙科焦虑量表的评分分别降低了 7.8 [SD:4.4;Cohen's d 效应大小:1.2(CI:0.8-1.7)]和 7.8 [SD:4.2;Cohen's d:1.4(0.9-1.8)],在 D-CBT 和四习惯/咪达唑仑组中分别为 1.2(0.8-1.7)和 1.4(0.9-1.8)。大多数患者(D-CBT 组为 74%,四习惯/咪达唑仑组为 80%)继续接受牙科治疗。D-CBT 组有 9 名患者和四习惯/咪达唑仑组有 7 名患者接受了心理学家/牙医团队提供的额外 CBT 治疗。接受过适当培训的牙医都可以使用这两种方法。普通牙科实践中针对牙科焦虑症的有效一线治疗方法可以为牙科焦虑症患者提供更易获得的治疗途径。基于证据的牙科焦虑症治疗方案应纳入牙科课程,并作为牙医的最佳实践。