Fioravanti Guido, Cameletti Michela, Martino Sara, Cattani Giorgio, Pisoni Enrico
Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale Rome Italy.
Department of Economics University of Bergamo Bergamo Italy.
Environmetrics. 2022 Jun;33(4):e2723. doi: 10.1002/env.2723. Epub 2022 Mar 12.
When a new environmental policy or a specific intervention is taken in order to improve air quality, it is paramount to assess and quantify-in space and time-the effectiveness of the adopted strategy. The lockdown measures taken worldwide in 2020 to reduce the spread of the SARS-CoV-2 virus can be envisioned as a policy intervention with an indirect effect on air quality. In this paper we propose a statistical spatiotemporal model as a tool for intervention analysis, able to take into account the effect of weather and other confounding factor, as well as the spatial and temporal correlation existing in the data. In particular, we focus here on the 2019/2020 relative change in nitrogen dioxide (NO ) concentrations in the north of Italy, for the period of March and April during which the lockdown measure was in force. We found that during March and April 2020 most of the studied area is characterized by negative relative changes (median values around 25%), with the exception of the first week of March and the fourth week of April (median values around 5%). As these changes cannot be attributed to a weather effect, it is likely that they are a byproduct of the lockdown measures. There are two aspects of our research that are equally interesting. First, we provide a unique statistical perspective for calculating the relative change in the NO by jointly modeling pollutant concentrations time series. Second, as an output we provide a collection of weekly continuous maps, describing the spatial pattern of the NO 2019/2020 relative changes.
当为改善空气质量而采取新的环境政策或特定干预措施时,在空间和时间上评估和量化所采用策略的有效性至关重要。2020年全球为减少SARS-CoV-2病毒传播而采取的封锁措施可被视为对空气质量有间接影响的政策干预。在本文中,我们提出一种统计时空模型作为干预分析工具,该模型能够考虑天气和其他混杂因素的影响,以及数据中存在的空间和时间相关性。特别是,我们在此关注意大利北部2019/2020年二氧化氮(NO₂)浓度在3月和4月封锁措施实施期间的相对变化。我们发现,在2020年3月和4月期间,除了3月的第一周和4月的第四周(中位数约为5%)外,大部分研究区域的特征是相对变化为负(中位数约为25%)。由于这些变化不能归因于天气影响,它们很可能是封锁措施的副产品。我们的研究有两个同样有趣的方面。首先,我们通过联合建模污染物浓度时间序列,为计算NO₂的相对变化提供了独特的统计视角。其次,作为输出,我们提供了一系列每周连续地图,描述了2019/2020年NO₂相对变化的空间模式。