Faculty of Electrical Engineering, University of Ljubljana, Tržaška 25, 1000, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Institute of Clinical Neurophysiology, University Medical Centre Ljubljana, Zaloška 2, 1000, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Sci Rep. 2022 May 16;12(1):8019. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-12112-9.
To minimize neuromuscular electrical stimulation during electroporation-based treatments, the replacement of long monophasic pulses with bursts of biphasic high-frequency pulses in the range of microseconds was suggested in order to reduce muscle contraction and pain sensation due to pulse application. This treatment modality appeared under the term high-frequency electroporation (HF-EP), which can be potentially used for some clinical applications of electroporation such as electrochemotherapy, gene electrotransfer, and tissue ablation. In cardiac tissue ablation, which utilizes irreversible electroporation, the treatment is being established as Pulsed Field Ablation. While the reduction of muscle contractions was confirmed in multiple in vivo studies, the reduction of pain sensation in humans was not confirmed yet, nor was the relationship between muscle contraction and pain sensation investigated. This is the first study in humans examining pain sensation using biphasic high-frequency electroporation pulses. Twenty-five healthy individuals were subjected to electrical stimulation of the tibialis anterior muscle with biphasic high-frequency pulses in the range of few microseconds and both, symmetric and asymmetric interphase and interpulse delays. Our results confirm that biphasic high-frequency pulses with a pulse width of 1 or 2 µs reduce muscle contraction and pain sensation as opposed to currently used longer monophasic pulses. In addition, interphase and interpulse delays play a significant role in reducing the muscle contraction and/or pain sensation. The study shows that the range of the optimal pulse parameters may be increased depending on the prerequisites of the therapy. However, further evaluation of the biphasic pulse protocols presented herein is necessary to confirm the efficiency of the newly proposed HF-EP.
为了在基于电穿孔的治疗中最小化神经肌肉电刺激,有人建议用微秒范围内的双相高频脉冲脉冲群替代单相长脉冲,以减少由于施加脉冲而引起的肌肉收缩和疼痛感觉。这种治疗方式被称为高频电穿孔(HF-EP),它可潜在地用于电穿孔的一些临床应用,如电化学治疗、基因电转移和组织消融。在利用不可逆电穿孔的心脏组织消融中,该治疗方法被确立为脉冲场消融。虽然在多项体内研究中证实了肌肉收缩的减少,但尚未证实人类疼痛感觉的减少,也未研究肌肉收缩与疼痛感觉之间的关系。这是第一项在人类中使用双相高频电穿孔脉冲检查疼痛感觉的研究。25 名健康个体接受了双相高频脉冲(范围在几微秒内)对胫骨前肌的电刺激,这些脉冲具有对称和非对称的相间和脉冲间延迟。我们的结果证实,与目前使用的较长单相脉冲相比,宽度为 1 或 2 μs 的双相高频脉冲可减少肌肉收缩和疼痛感觉。此外,相间和脉冲间延迟在减少肌肉收缩和/或疼痛感觉方面起着重要作用。该研究表明,根据治疗的前提条件,可以增加最佳脉冲参数的范围。但是,需要进一步评估本文提出的双相脉冲方案,以确认新提出的 HF-EP 的效率。