Department of Biomedical Engineering, College of Health Science, Gachon University, Incheon 21936, Korea.
Department of Health Sciences and Technology, Gachon Advanced Institute for Health Sciences and Technology (GAIHST), Gil Medical Center, Gachon University, Incheon 21936, Korea.
Sensors (Basel). 2022 Apr 20;22(9):3143. doi: 10.3390/s22093143.
Chest radiography is one of the most widely used diagnostic methods in hospitals, but it is difficult to read clearly because several human organ tissues and bones overlap. Therefore, various image processing and rib segmentation methods have been proposed to focus on the desired target. However, it is challenging to segment ribs elaborately using deep learning because they cannot reflect the characteristics of each region. Identifying which region has specific characteristics vulnerable to deep learning is an essential indicator of developing segmentation methods in medical imaging. Therefore, it is necessary to compare the deep learning performance differences based on regional characteristics. This study compares the differences in deep learning performance based on the rib region to verify whether deep learning reflects the characteristics of each part and to demonstrate why this regional performance difference has occurred. We utilized 195 normal chest X-ray datasets with data augmentation for learning and 5-fold cross-validation. To compare segmentation performance, the rib image was divided vertically and horizontally based on the spine, clavicle, heart, and lower organs, which are characteristic indicators of the baseline chest X-ray. Resultingly, we found that the deep learning model showed a 6-7% difference in the segmentation performance depending on the regional characteristics of the rib. We verified that the performance differences in each region cannot be ignored. This study will enable a more precise segmentation of the ribs and the development of practical deep learning algorithms.
胸部 X 光摄影是医院中最广泛使用的诊断方法之一,但由于几个人体器官组织和骨骼重叠,因此难以清晰阅读。因此,已经提出了各种图像处理和肋骨分割方法,以关注所需的目标。然而,由于深度学习无法反映每个区域的特征,因此精细地分割肋骨具有挑战性。确定哪个区域具有特定的、容易受到深度学习影响的特征是开发医学影像分割方法的重要指标。因此,有必要基于区域特征来比较深度学习性能的差异。本研究基于肋骨区域比较深度学习性能的差异,以验证深度学习是否反映了每个部分的特征,并说明为什么会出现这种区域性能差异。我们使用了 195 个具有数据增强功能的正常胸部 X 射线数据集进行学习,并进行了 5 倍交叉验证。为了比较分割性能,根据脊柱、锁骨、心脏和下部器官等基线胸部 X 射线的特征指标,将肋骨图像垂直和水平分割。结果表明,深度学习模型的分割性能根据肋骨的区域特征存在 6-7%的差异。我们验证了每个区域的性能差异不容忽视。本研究将能够更精确地分割肋骨并开发实用的深度学习算法。