Inturrisi Federica, Berkhof Johannes
Epidemiology and Data Science, Amsterdam UMC location Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Amsterdam Public Health, Methodology, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
J Med Econ. 2022 Jan-Dec;25(1):762-768. doi: 10.1080/13696998.2022.2082777.
Human papillomavirus (HPV) testing has been recommended by the WHO as the first choice method in cervical cancer screening. So far, only a limited number of countries have implemented primary HPV testing, partly because of the assumed high costs of HPV testing. We assessed tender-based prices of HPV testing in Italy, where programmatic HPV-based screening has been implemented at the regional level.
Procurement notices and awards, published between 2014 and December 2021, were retrieved from the European online platform for public procurement. The unit price per HPV test was calculated as the ratio of the contract award price and contract volume. The association between the unit price and contract volume, calendar year, number of offers, region's per capita gross domestic product and population density was assessed by linear regression. Fractional polynomials were used to describe the association between the unit price and contract volume.
We retrieved data from 29 procurement procedures. The median unit price per HPV test was €10.75, ranging from €4.30 to €204.80. The unit price was not higher than €5 for 6 out of 11 contract awards with a volume of at least 100,000 tests. After discarding two low-volume contracts with very high contract prices (€182.40 and €204.80), volume explained 86.5% of the variation in unit price. The unit price was not associated with other variables.
The Italian experience showed that the tender-based unit price of an HPV test is very low when procured at high volume, indicating that there is no reason for countries to further delay the implementation of HPV-based screening because of prohibitively high HPV testing costs.
世界卫生组织已推荐人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)检测作为宫颈癌筛查的首选方法。到目前为止,只有少数国家实施了HPV初筛,部分原因是认为HPV检测成本高昂。我们评估了意大利基于招标的HPV检测价格,该国已在地区层面实施了基于HPV的筛查计划。
从欧洲公共采购在线平台检索2014年至2021年12月期间发布的采购公告和中标信息。HPV检测的单价计算为中标价格与合同数量之比。通过线性回归评估单价与合同数量、日历年、报价数量、地区人均国内生产总值和人口密度之间的关联。使用分数多项式描述单价与合同数量之间的关联。
我们从29个采购程序中检索到数据。HPV检测的中位单价为10.75欧元,范围为4.30欧元至204.80欧元。在11份合同数量至少为100,000次检测的中标合同中,有6份的单价不高于5欧元。在剔除两份合同价格极高(182.40欧元和204.80欧元)的小批量合同后,合同数量解释了单价变化的86.5%。单价与其他变量无关。
意大利的经验表明,大量采购时基于招标的HPV检测单价非常低,这表明各国没有理由因HPV检测成本过高而进一步推迟实施基于HPV的筛查。