Radiotherapy Department, Cancer Centre of Trinidad and Tobago, St James, Trinidad and Tobago.
University of the West Indies, St. Augustine, Trinidad & Tobago.
Br J Radiol. 2022 Aug 1;95(1136):20201289. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20201289. Epub 2022 Jul 4.
Modern conformal radiation therapy using techniques such as modulation, image guidance and motion management have changed the face of radiotherapy today offering superior conformity, efficiency, and reproducibility to clinics worldwide. This review assesses the impact of these advanced radiotherapy techniques on patient toxicity and survival rates reported from January 2017 to September 2020. The main aims are to establish if dosimetric and efficiency gains correlate with improved survival and reduced toxicities and to answer the question 'What is the clinical evidence for the most effective implementation of VMAT?'. Compared with 3DCRT, improvements have been reported with VMAT in prostate, locally advanced cervical carcinoma and various head and neck applications, leading to the shift in technology to VMAT. Other sites such as thoracic neoplasms and nasopharyngeal carcinomas have observed some improvement with VMAT although not in line with improved dosimetric measures, and the burden of toxicity and the incidence of cancer related deaths remain high, signaling the need to further mitigate toxicity and increase survival. As technological advancement continues, large randomised long-term clinical trials are required to determine the way-forward and offer site-specific recommendations. These studies are usually expensive and time consuming, therefore utilising pooled real-world data in a prospective nature can be an alternative solution to comprehensively assess the efficacy of modern radiotherapy techniques.
现代适形放射治疗技术,如调强、图像引导和运动管理,改变了当今放射治疗的面貌,为全球临床提供了更好的适形性、效率和可重复性。本综述评估了 2017 年 1 月至 2020 年 9 月期间,这些先进的放射治疗技术对患者毒性和生存率的影响。主要目的是确定剂量学和效率的提高是否与生存率的提高和毒性的降低相关,并回答“VMAT 的最有效实施的临床证据是什么?”的问题。与 3DCRT 相比,VMAT 在前列腺癌、局部晚期宫颈癌和各种头颈部应用中已被报道有改善,从而导致技术向 VMAT 转移。其他部位,如胸肿瘤和鼻咽癌,虽然与改善的剂量学措施不一致,但观察到 VMAT 有一些改善,毒性负担和癌症相关死亡的发生率仍然很高,表明需要进一步减轻毒性并提高生存率。随着技术的不断进步,需要进行大型随机长期临床试验来确定前进的方向,并提供特定部位的建议。这些研究通常昂贵且耗时,因此以前瞻性的方式利用真实世界的数据进行汇总分析可以是评估现代放射治疗技术疗效的一种替代方案。