Xavier Salomé M, Jarvis G Eric, Ouellet-Plamondon Clairélaine, Gagné Geneviève, Abdel-Baki Amal, Iyer Srividya N
Département de psychiatrie, Université McGill, Montréal ; Centre de recherche Douglas et Clinique PEPP-Montréal (Programme de prévention et d'intervention précoce pour la psychose), Montréal.
Département de psychiatrie, Université McGill, Montréal, Division de psychiatrie sociale et transculturelle, Université McGill, Montréal ; Service de consultation culturelle et Unité de recherche en culture et santé mentale, Hôpital Général Juif, Montréal.
Sante Ment Que. 2021 Fall;46(2):331-364.
Objectives To synthesize the available epidemiological and clinical evidence relevant to the mental health care of migrant, ethnic minority and Indigenous populations in the context of early psychosis. Methods This study provides a narrative review of the literature on psychosis in these populations, including issues related to the provision of early intervention services for psychosis. Results Migrant status has long been reported as a significant risk factor for psychosis in many geographic contexts. This increased risk among migrants seems to persist beyond the first generation and has been found to be higher in all migrant populations, but especially for black ethnic minorities and individuals migrating from economically developing countries to developed ones. Recent evidence suggests that this higher risk is at least in part due to migrants' and minorities' cumulative exposure to social adversities, such as racial discrimination, marginalization and socio-economic disadvantage. Systemic racism affects migrant and minority populations by creating bias in diagnostic practices and aggravating treatment disparities in addition to contributing to causation of psychosis. Furthermore, migrant and ethnic minority groups are known to seek mental healthcare after longer delays, to be more frequently forcibly hospitalized, to disengage from treatment prematurely and to be less satisfied with their treatment. The consideration of social and cultural context and factors is essential to the provision of good healthcare, especially in a culturally diverse society. Furthermore, acknowledging power relationships that stem from the societal context and shape institutions and models of care is a key step towards structural competence and safety in mental healthcare. Several strategies have been proposed to make mental healthcare services and systems more culturally and structurally competent. These include the use of interpreters and cultural brokers, tailored assessments and specialised cultural interventions. However, these strategies have yet to be adopted broadly in early intervention for psychosis. Conclusion Given its emphasis on meaningful engagement and person-centered care, early intervention should integrate inclusive, structurally competent and context-informed interventions as a priority. Efforts must be made to apply knowledge from and adapt the tools of social and cultural psychiatry to the field of early intervention in psychosis. Sociocultural considerations, hitherto inconsistently applied in psychosis research and service design in Quebec, are especially relevant to the province given its distinct linguistic context, its increasing cultural diversity, and its ongoing effort to systematize and expand the delivery of early intervention services.
目标 在早期精神病的背景下,综合与移民、少数族裔和原住民心理健康护理相关的现有流行病学和临床证据。方法 本研究对这些人群中精神病的文献进行了叙述性综述,包括与提供精神病早期干预服务相关的问题。结果 长期以来,在许多地理环境中,移民身份一直被报告为精神病的一个重要风险因素。移民中的这种风险增加似乎在第一代之后仍然存在,并且在所有移民群体中都被发现更高,尤其是黑人少数族裔以及从经济发展中国家迁移到发达国家的个人。最近的证据表明,这种较高的风险至少部分归因于移民和少数族裔累积遭受的社会逆境,如种族歧视、边缘化和社会经济劣势。系统性种族主义除了导致精神病外,还通过在诊断实践中产生偏见和加剧治疗差异来影响移民和少数族裔群体。此外,已知移民和少数族裔群体寻求心理保健的延迟时间更长,更频繁地被强制住院,过早停止治疗,并且对治疗的满意度较低。考虑社会和文化背景及因素对于提供良好的医疗保健至关重要,尤其是在文化多元的社会中。此外,认识到源于社会背景并塑造护理机构和模式的权力关系是实现心理保健结构能力和安全性的关键一步。已经提出了几种策略以使心理保健服务和系统在文化和结构上更具能力。这些策略包括使用口译员和文化中介、量身定制的评估和专门的文化干预措施。然而,这些策略尚未在精神病早期干预中广泛采用。结论 鉴于早期干预强调有意义的参与和以患者为中心的护理,应优先整合包容性、结构上有能力且基于背景的干预措施。必须努力将社会和文化精神病学的知识应用于精神病早期干预领域,并对其工具进行调整。社会文化考量在魁北克的精神病研究和服务设计中迄今应用不一致,鉴于该省独特的语言环境、日益增加的文化多样性以及其正在进行的系统化和扩大早期干预服务提供的努力,这些考量与该省尤为相关。