Department of Legal Medicine, Ethics and Occupational Health, Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
Discipline of Legal Medicine and Bioethics, Faculdade de Medicina do ABC, Santo André, SP, Brazil.
Clinics (Sao Paulo). 2022 May 28;77:100053. doi: 10.1016/j.clinsp.2022.100053. eCollection 2022.
Error in medicine and medical liability has a long history dating back to Antiquity. During the 19th Century, most lawsuits related to errors in treating surgical problems were settled. However, in the first half of the 20th Century, lawsuits claimed that mistakes were related to the doctor's action: the doctor made something wrong (errors of commission). In Brazil, medical error is defined as inappropriate conduct, including negligence and recklessness, that causes harm to the patient. The physician's fear of being suited is the reason for some practice named defensive Medicine (D.M.), defined as ordering unnecessary tests and procedures or avoiding treatments for patients considered at high-risk. Thus, this narrative review aims to analyze and describe the relationship between medical errors, medical negligence, and the practice of D.M. So, the authors propose procedures and attitudes to avoid medical errors and the approach of D.M.: a national focus to create leadership and research tools to enhance the knowledge base about patient safety; a reporting system that would help to identify and learn from errors; the use of a computer-based protocol reminder; some technological devices to help the medical practice (electronic prescribing and information technology systems); creating risk management programs in hospitals. Therefore, the authors conclude that the most critical attitude to avoid medical liability is a good and ethical medical practice with the proper use of technology, based on knowledge of scientific evidence and ethical principles of medicine - for the benefit of patients.
医学错误和医疗责任的历史由来已久,可以追溯到古代。19 世纪,大多数与治疗手术问题有关的错误相关诉讼都得到了解决。然而,在 20 世纪上半叶,诉讼声称错误与医生的行为有关:医生做错了什么(作为错误)。在巴西,医疗错误被定义为不当行为,包括疏忽和鲁莽,对患者造成伤害。医生害怕被起诉是一些名为防御性医疗(Defensive Medicine,D.M.)的实践的原因,它被定义为对被认为高风险的患者进行不必要的检查和程序,或避免治疗。因此,本叙述性综述旨在分析和描述医疗错误、医疗过失与 D.M. 实践之间的关系。因此,作者提出了一些程序和态度来避免医疗错误和 D.M. 实践:国家重点是创建领导和研究工具,以增强对患者安全知识基础的了解;一个报告系统,将有助于识别和从错误中吸取教训;使用基于计算机的医嘱提醒程序;一些有助于医疗实践的技术设备(电子处方和信息技术系统);在医院创建风险管理计划。因此,作者得出结论,避免医疗责任的最关键态度是良好和合乎道德的医疗实践,适当利用技术,基于科学证据和医学伦理原则——为了患者的利益。