Lim Mei Ling, Tran Mymy, van Schooten Kimberley S, Radford Kylie A, O'Dea Bridianne, Baldwin Peter, Delbaere Kim
Falls, Balance and Injury Research Centre, Neuroscience Research Australia, Sydney, Australia.
School of Population Health, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
Int J Behav Med. 2023 Jun;30(3):455-462. doi: 10.1007/s12529-022-10105-6. Epub 2022 Jun 2.
Traditional face-to-face cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) has been successful at reducing fear of falling (FOF) in older people but can be labour-intensive and costly. Online CBT has been suggested as a cost-effective alternative but has not yet been tested in the context of FOF. This study evaluates the effectiveness of a readily available, self-guided and generalised online CBT program (myCompass) on reducing FOF in older people.
Fifty community-dwelling older people with FOF received a paper-based health education program, and half were randomly assigned to receive three selected modules from myCompass for 6 weeks. The primary outcome was feared consequences of falling at 6 weeks. Secondary outcomes were concern about falling, balance confidence, activity avoidance, physical activity, exercise self-efficacy, health literacy and mental health at 6/26/52 weeks and falls incidence at 12 months.
All intervention participants completed at least 2-out-of-3 myCompass modules. There was a significant main effect of time on feared consequences of falling (Cohen's f = 0.55). The group by time interactions for concern about falling (f = 0.28), stress (f = 0.26) and social support for health (health literacy) (f = 0.26) was also significant, favouring the control group. The overall attrition rate at 12 months was 24% (n = 12).
The high program compliance and low attrition rate suggest that online CBT is feasible among older people. However, the myCompass program had no effect at reducing FOF in older people. A more targeted CBT program with a well-integrated psychoeducation module on FOF might be the solution to boost the therapeutic effects of a generalised CBT program at reducing FOF for older people.
传统的面对面认知行为疗法(CBT)在降低老年人跌倒恐惧(FOF)方面已取得成功,但可能劳动强度大且成本高。有人提出在线CBT是一种具有成本效益的替代方法,但尚未在FOF背景下进行测试。本研究评估一种现成的、自我指导的通用在线CBT程序(myCompass)在降低老年人FOF方面的有效性。
50名患有FOF的社区居住老年人接受了纸质健康教育计划,其中一半被随机分配接受myCompass的三个选定模块,为期6周。主要结局是6周时跌倒的恐惧后果。次要结局是6/26/52周时对跌倒的担忧、平衡信心、活动回避、身体活动、运动自我效能、健康素养和心理健康,以及12个月时的跌倒发生率。
所有干预参与者至少完成了myCompass三个模块中的两个。时间对跌倒恐惧后果有显著的主效应(科恩f值=0.55)。时间与组的交互作用对跌倒担忧(f值=0.28)、压力(f值=0.26)和健康社会支持(健康素养)(f值=0.26)也有显著影响,有利于对照组。12个月时的总体损耗率为24%(n=12)。
高项目依从性和低损耗率表明在线CBT在老年人中是可行的。然而,myCompass程序在降低老年人FOF方面没有效果。一个更有针对性的CBT程序,其中有一个关于FOF的精心整合的心理教育模块,可能是提高通用CBT程序在降低老年人FOF方面治疗效果的解决方案。