Center for Primary Health Care Network Management, Deputy for Public Health, Iranian Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran, Iran.
Center for Health Human Resources Research and Studies, Iran Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran, Iran.
BMC Public Health. 2022 Jun 18;22(1):1218. doi: 10.1186/s12889-022-13621-y.
The overwhelming outbreak of covid-19 has forced governments all over the world to consider different measures to face this challenging situation. A vitally important element to the declining transmission of viruses is changing behaviors based on reliable information. This study was designed and implemented to identify factors affecting the preventive behaviors during the covid-19 pandemic.
This thematic synthesis was carried out in order to create a set of central themes that summarize all of the issues raised in the articles reviewed in this study. We used PRISMA 2020 guidelines to direct this systematic review and meta synthesis. The process of analyzing data includes three different stages: 1) creating codes; 2) production of descriptive themes; 3) and finally, the creation of analytical themes. The Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research checklist was used to evaluate the articles' quality.
Five central themes emerged from 8 included articles, (1) Social factors (subthemes: environmental context, political leadership, multimedia), (2) Cultural factors (subthemes: national culture, religious culture, the family beliefs, work culture, foreign culture), (3) Economic factors (subthemes: economic situation of the individual, the government supports, infrastructures), (4) Personal factors (subthemes: people experiences, cognitive ability, physical factors, different motivational level, sense of responsibility, risk management, and self-management skills), and (5) Knowledge and Education factors (subthemes: access to information, skill training). Furthermore, SRQR items that were weakly reported were "researcher characteristics and reflexivity", "Sampling strategy", "Data collection methods", "Data analysis", and "techniques to enhance trustworthiness.
Health policymakers and other public health officials in various countries can use the factors listed to develop appropriate, evidence-based policies. They should investigate behavioral characteristics in their community based on their abilities, and then design and implement appropriate executive actions.
新冠疫情的爆发迫使全球各国政府考虑采取不同措施来应对这一具有挑战性的局面。改变行为以获取可靠信息是病毒传播率下降的一个至关重要的因素。本研究旨在确定影响新冠疫情期间预防行为的因素。
为了总结综述中所审查文章提出的所有问题,我们进行了此次主题综合分析,以创建一套核心主题。我们使用 PRISMA 2020 指南来指导这项系统评价和元综合。数据分析过程包括三个不同阶段:1)创建代码;2)生成描述性主题;3)最后,创建分析性主题。我们使用定性研究报告标准清单来评估文章的质量。
从 8 篇纳入文章中得出了 5 个核心主题,(1)社会因素(亚主题:环境背景、政治领导、多媒体);(2)文化因素(亚主题:国家文化、宗教文化、家庭信仰、工作文化、外国文化);(3)经济因素(亚主题:个人经济状况、政府支持、基础设施);(4)个人因素(亚主题:个人经历、认知能力、身体因素、不同的动机水平、责任感、风险管理和自我管理技能);(5)知识和教育因素(亚主题:信息获取、技能培训)。此外,报告质量较弱的 SRQR 项目包括“研究人员特征和反思”、“抽样策略”、“数据收集方法”、“数据分析”和“提高可信度的技术”。
各国的卫生政策制定者和其他公共卫生官员可以利用列出的因素制定适当的、基于证据的政策。他们应该根据自己的能力调查社区中的行为特征,然后设计和实施适当的执行行动。