Social Perceptions of Science Lab, Department of Biology, Middle Tennessee State University, Murfreesboro, TN 37132.
Biology Department, Chandler-Gilbert Community College, Chandler, AZ 85225.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2022 Sep;21(3):ar46. doi: 10.1187/cbe.21-09-0229.
Learning about evolution is a foundational part of biology education, but most current studies that explore college student evolution education are conducted at universities. However, community college students tend to be more diverse in characteristics shown to be related to evolution education outcomes. To explore how studies involving university students may generalize to community college students, we surveyed students from seven community college ( = 202) and nine university ( = 2288) classes. We measured students' evolution interest, acceptance, and understanding, and for religious students, we measured their perceived conflict between their religions and evolution. Controlling for state and major, we found that community college students had similar levels of evolution interest as university students but perceived greater conflict between their religions and evolution. Further, community college students had lower evolution understanding and acceptance compared with university students. Religiosity was a strong factor predicting community college and university students' evolution acceptance. However, unique to community college students, evolution understanding was not related to their macroevolution or human evolution acceptance. This indicates that, although some results between community college and university students are similar, there are differences that have implications for evolution instruction that warrant the need for more evolution education research at community colleges.
学习进化论是生物学教育的基础部分,但目前大多数探索大学生进化论教育的研究都是在大学进行的。然而,社区大学生在与进化论教育成果相关的特征上往往更加多样化。为了探讨涉及大学生的研究如何推广到社区大学生,我们调查了来自七所社区大学(=202 人)和九所大学(=2288 人)的学生。我们测量了学生对进化论的兴趣、接受度和理解程度,对于宗教学生,我们测量了他们认为宗教与进化论之间的冲突。控制州和专业,我们发现社区大学生与大学生的进化论兴趣水平相似,但认为宗教与进化论之间的冲突更大。此外,社区大学生的进化论理解和接受程度低于大学生。宗教信仰是预测社区大学生和大学生进化论接受程度的一个重要因素。然而,对于社区大学生来说,进化论理解与他们对宏观进化或人类进化的接受程度无关。这表明,尽管社区大学生和大学生之间存在一些相似的结果,但也存在一些差异,这些差异对进化论教学有影响,因此需要在社区学院进行更多的进化论教育研究。