Jenkins Hazel J, Moloney Niamh A, French Simon D, Maher Chris G, Dear Blake F, Magnussen John S, Hancock Mark J
Department of Health Professions, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Human Sciences, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia.
Department of Chiropractic, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Human Sciences, Macquarie University, Level 2, 75 Talavera Rd, Sydney, 2109, Australia.
Implement Sci Commun. 2022 Jun 28;3(1):71. doi: 10.1186/s43058-022-00317-y.
Imaging is overused in the management of low back pain, resulting in overdiagnosis, increased healthcare utilisation, and increased costs. Few effective interventions to decrease inappropriate use have been developed and have typically not been developed using behaviour change theory. An intervention to reduce non-indicated imaging for low back pain was developed using behavioural change theory, incorporating a novel low back pain management booklet to facilitate patient education and reassurance. The aim of this study was to assess the adoption and feasibility of use of the developed intervention within clinical practice and to determine appropriate implementation strategies to address identified barriers to use.
Fourteen general medical practitioners were recruited and trained to use the booklet with low back pain patients over a minimum 5-month period. Quantitative data on use of the booklet were collected and analysed descriptively. Qualitative data on use of the booklet and training session were collected in general medical practitioner interviews and thematically analysed. Barriers to use were identified and mapped to suitable implementation strategies using the Behaviour Change Wheel.
Practitioners used the booklet with 73 patients. The booklet was used with 63% of patients presenting with low back pain. Facilitators for using the booklet included patient's requesting imaging and lower practitioner confidence in managing low back pain. Barriers included accessible storage and remembering to use the booklet. Implementation strategies were identified to increase adoption and feasibility of use, including development of a digital version of the booklet.
General medical practitioners reported that the low back pain management booklet and training were useful for clinical practice, particularly with patients requesting imaging. Barriers to use were identified and implementation strategies to address these barriers will be incorporated into future effectiveness studies. This study forms one of a series of studies to thoroughly develop and test an intervention to reduce non-indicated imaging for low back pain; a successful intervention would decrease healthcare costs and improve patient management.
在腰痛管理中,影像学检查存在过度使用的情况,导致过度诊断、医疗资源利用增加和成本上升。目前很少有有效的干预措施来减少不恰当的使用,而且这些措施通常不是基于行为改变理论开发的。我们基于行为改变理论开发了一种减少腰痛非必要影像学检查的干预措施,其中纳入了一本新颖的腰痛管理手册,以促进患者教育和安抚。本研究的目的是评估所开发的干预措施在临床实践中的采用情况和使用可行性,并确定适当的实施策略以克服已识别的使用障碍。
招募了14名全科医生,并对他们进行培训,使其在至少5个月的时间内对腰痛患者使用该手册。收集并描述性分析了关于手册使用的定量数据。通过对全科医生的访谈收集了关于手册使用和培训课程的定性数据,并进行了主题分析。使用行为改变轮识别使用障碍,并将其与合适的实施策略进行匹配。
医生们对手册的73名患者使用了该手册。63%的腰痛患者使用了该手册。使用手册的促进因素包括患者要求进行影像学检查以及医生对管理腰痛的信心较低。障碍包括易于获取的存放位置以及记住使用手册。确定了提高采用率和使用可行性的实施策略,包括开发手册的数字版本。
全科医生报告称,腰痛管理手册和培训对临床实践很有用,特别是对于要求进行影像学检查的患者。识别出了使用障碍,解决这些障碍的实施策略将纳入未来的有效性研究中。本研究是一系列深入开发和测试减少腰痛非必要影像学检查干预措施的研究之一;成功的干预措施将降低医疗成本并改善患者管理。