Woo Su Mei, Whale Jonathan
Discipline of Engineering and Energy, College of Science, Health, Engineering and Education, Murdoch University, Murdoch, WA, Australia.
Waste Manag Res. 2022 Dec;40(12):1730-1744. doi: 10.1177/0734242X221105434. Epub 2022 Jun 28.
Renewable energy generation and increased electrification are pivotal to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigating climate change. Consequently, global deployment of wind turbines has soared, and the trend is expected to continue. Installed turbines have only recently started reaching the end of their design lives, and waste volumes are projected to escalate rapidly. Approximately 94% of a wind turbine (by mass) is recyclable, but the waste polymer composite blades are most commonly landfilled. This mini-review aims to review current end-of-life (EoL) management practices in the large-scale wind industry for countries with established EoL standards as well as those with less mature regulations. Data on current EoL management practices, initiatives and regulations in industry was sourced primarily from literature reviews and publicly available internet information. Additional insights and perspectives were gained from WindEurope's EoL Issues and Strategies 2020 seminar and through communication with select individuals from various sectors such as wind energy development and operations, government, industry associations, academia and research organizations. The results show that the decision on EoL options is dictated by the remaining useful life (RUL) of the wind turbines, prevailing policies and electricity prices. The contribution of this article is, firstly, identifying a number of key technical, economic and regulatory questions that must be asked before deciding on the most appropriate EoL option. Secondly, the article identifies factors that impede current EoL management efforts to close the circular economy gap and those that can support sustainable technology deployment. Finally, the article considers the way that countries with a young fleet of wind farms may learn from more experienced nations. There are few proven business cases, and barriers to the profitability and effectiveness of EoL strategies include uncertainty about the assets' RUL, collection logistics, the size of wind farm operation margins, low waste feedstock and limited markets for recycled products. Designing for circularity, stakeholder collaboration, circular business models and technology-specific regulations can improve EoL sustainability. The research found that wind turbine EoL management is dynamic and complex and needs to consider multiple, often conflicting factors. However, it is necessary and has immense environmental, technical and economic potential as the industry matures and business cases are proven.
可再生能源发电和电气化程度的提高对于减少温室气体排放和缓解气候变化至关重要。因此,全球风力涡轮机的部署激增,且这一趋势预计将持续。已安装的涡轮机直到最近才开始达到其设计寿命的终点,预计废弃物量将迅速增加。风力涡轮机约94%(按质量计)是可回收的,但废弃的聚合物复合材料叶片最常被填埋。本综述旨在回顾大规模风电行业中,对于有既定报废标准的国家以及法规不太成熟的国家,当前的报废管理实践。关于行业当前报废管理实践、举措和法规的数据主要来自文献综述和公开的互联网信息。通过欧洲风能协会2020年报废问题与策略研讨会,以及与风能开发与运营、政府、行业协会、学术界和研究组织等各部门的特定人员交流,获得了更多见解和观点。结果表明,报废选项的决策取决于风力涡轮机的剩余使用寿命、现行政策和电价。本文的贡献在于,首先,确定了在决定最合适的报废选项之前必须提出的一些关键技术、经济和监管问题。其次,本文确定了阻碍当前报废管理努力以弥合循环经济差距的因素,以及那些能够支持可持续技术部署的因素。最后,本文考虑了拥有年轻风电场群的国家可以如何向更有经验国家学习的方式。几乎没有经过验证的商业案例,报废策略的盈利能力和有效性的障碍包括资产剩余使用寿命的不确定性、收集物流、风电场运营利润率的大小、低废弃原料以及回收产品市场有限。为循环利用而设计、利益相关者合作、循环商业模式和特定技术法规可以提高报废的可持续性。研究发现,风力涡轮机报废管理是动态且复杂的,需要考虑多个往往相互冲突的因素。然而,随着行业成熟且商业案例得到验证,这是必要且具有巨大的环境、技术和经济潜力的。